• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Pursuing truth toward justice

The Valley Citizen

Pursuing truth toward justice
  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About

Another Huge Loss for Oakdale Irrigation District

November 28, 2018 By Eric Caine 2 Comments

Gail Altieri and Landa Santos, City Towers, Modesto

For any other public entity, the loss suffered on November 27 by Oakdale Irrigation District (OID) in Fresno’s Fifth Appellate District Court would amount to a wake-up call, but given the resistance to facts of three of its board members, General Manager and water attorney, it’s unlikely any of them will come away with a lesson learned.

This, after all, is the water district whose own attorney told them they would need an Environmental Impact Review (EIR) before instituting a fallowing program and subsequent water sale and then failed to perform the review. As if that weren’t enough, after getting caught failing to perform the review, the same OID attorney who had recommended the review argued in court the review wasn’t needed.

OID Board members should have gotten a clue last year when Superior Court Judge Roger Beauchesne lectured their attorneys about the use of ad hominem arguments in a court of law and went so far as to read aloud the definition. They should have realized they had no case at all when Judge Beauchesne wrote that the Oakdale Groundwater Alliance (OGA) had provided a “public service” by insisting OID should do an EIR. Instead, OID Board Members and management decided to appeal Beuchesne’s decision.

Actually, to be entirely accurate, it was three of the five board members who supported the appeal. The two women on the board, Gail Altieri and Linda Santos, had argued from the beginning that OID should perform required EIRs before offering fallowing programs and selling water. And just for their troubles, their fellow board members sued them and slapped them with an injunction.

Yes, that’s right. When Altieri and Santos offered truthful testimony to Judge Beauchesne, their fellow board members accused them of revealing details discussed in an OID closed session and tried to muzzle them. In that case, the judge told OID the injunction, “would amount to placing handcuffs on Defendants’ ability to effectively operate as duly elected members of the Plaintiff’s Board of Directors,” and ruled against the district. OID then appealed that decision; the appeal is still pending.

But for OID Board members Herman Doornebal, Brad DeBoer, and Tom Orvis, court losses, facts and the law are just bumps in the road on the way to their yearly mission of selling water to buyers down south so a few OID farmers can get their own water below the cost of delivery. And the fallowing program? Just another cash cow for district farmers.

Theoretically, OID farmers receive cash credits to “improve” fallowed land. The improvements are usually in the form of replacing rangeland with almond orchards. The water saved from the fallowed land is then sold to buyers outside the district—most often Westlands Water District.

Touted by OID management as a “win/win,” the fallowing plan violates any number of directives imposed by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) but could conceivably be successful if OID performed the required EIR. OGA members Louis Brichetto and Robert Frobose have argued that the major flaw in the plan is its failure to address effects on groundwater.

OID’s own studies show a consistent decline in the local groundwater basin. Coupled with water sales outside the district, the decline would seem to most observers to represent a failure to comply with requirements imposed by the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA), a new state program designed to prevent the depletion of the state’s rapidly disappearing groundwater.

The most obvious way to address declines in groundwater is by the application of surface water in lieu of pumping. Just outside OID’s boundaries, but still within its sphere of influence, tens of thousands of acres of almond orchards are wholly dependent on groundwater. Most of the owners of those orchards would prefer to buy OID surface water, but the district has thus far preferred to sell outside the region.

OID has responded to court restrictions on water sales in a number of ways, including by temporarily abandoning its own water rights so that the so-called “surplus” water can be sold outside the district. When OID’s most recent attempt at a fallowing program ran into the brick wall of CEQA requirements, OID went ahead and paid farmers to fallow anyway, even without the compensation of a water sale.

The biggest payout—$331,000— went to OID farmer John Brichetto. Other payouts amounted to additional hundreds of thousands of dollars.

While OID’s water policies may seem complex and labyrinthine to the casual observer, they boil down to a relatively simple principle. The fundamental rule is to provide district farmers with water below the cost of delivery. Without public scrutiny, the simplest way to do so is by selling water to buyers outside the region.

Louis Brichetto, attorney Patrick Soluri, Bob Frobose, City Towers, Modesto

But given public scrutiny, OID’s programs reveal a fundamental violation of the public trust. By selling local water outside the region, OID is hurting the common interest in favor of subsidizing a few farmers, many of them very wealthy. The subsidies—really just payouts in some cases—result in favorable votes for those OID board members who support water sales. It’s a circle of payouts and vote-buying much like one might see in a banana republic.

In this latest case of rebuke by the court of appeals, OID is required to pay not only its own court costs, but those of the Oakdale Groundwater Alliance. The total will almost certainly be well over half a million dollars. Coupled with payouts for a fallowing program that was never court-approved, OID has paid a few powerful farmers millions of dollars strictly on the basis of their wealth and power. That’s not a public institution, it’s an oligarchy. OID Board members Doornenbal, DeBoer, and Orvis have a lot to answer for.

Filed Under: Environment Tagged With: Gail Altieri, Linda Santos Oakdale Irrigation District, Oakdale Irrigation District Fallowing Program, Oakdale Irrigation District water sales

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Damon Woods says

    November 28, 2018 at 8:22 pm

    I sure hope OID learns a lesson.

    Reply
  2. Portugal says

    January 26, 2020 at 12:35 am

    In the process, the board will have to answer a fundamental question: how much water do Californians need and how much should be left for endangered fish?

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

California faces catastrophic flood dangers ? and a need to invest billions in protection
California faces catastrophic flood dangers and a need to invest billions in protection
A new state plan for the Central Valley calls for spending as much as $30 billion over 30 years to prepare for the dangers.
www.latimes.com
Oakland will get millions for the ?inhumane? crisis at one huge homeless encampment. Officials say it?s not enough
Oakland will get millions for the “inhumane” crisis at one huge homeless encampment. Officials say it’s not enough
Gavin Newsom’s administration has awarded Oakland a $4.7 million grant to come up with…
www.sfchronicle.com
Alaska?s Fisheries Are Collapsing. This Congresswoman Is Taking on the Industry She Says Is to Blame.
Alaska’s Fisheries Are Collapsing. This Congresswoman Is Taking on the Industry She Says Is to Blame.
Mary Peltola won her election by campaigning on a platform to save the state’s prized fisheries. A powerful fishing lobby is standing in her way.
www.politico.com
Jimmy Carter's final foe: A parasitic worm that preyed on millions in Africa and Asia
Jimmy Carter’s final foe: A parasitic worm that preyed on millions in Africa and Asia
One of former President Carter’s biggest hopes is wiping out an infectious parasitic disease that’s plagued humans for millennia. How close is he?
www.latimes.com
Climate Extremes Threaten California?s Central Valley Songbirds - Eos
Climate Extremes Threaten California’s Central Valley Songbirds – Eos
A “nestbox highway” in California’s Central Valley is guiding songbirds to safe nesting sites and giving scientists a peek at fledgling success in a changing climate.
eos.org
Alaska Republican touts benefits of children being abused to death
Alaska Republican touts benefits of children being abused to death
Republican David Eastman suggested the death of child abuse victims could be a “cost savings” to wider society.
www.newsweek.com
Editorial: Newsom's drought order amid wet winter threatens iconic California species
Editorial: Newsom’s drought order amid wet winter threatens iconic California species
Gov. Gavin Newsom has effectively ended environmental regulations protecting California rivers and migratory fish by extending drought-year waivers.
www.latimes.com
Two-thirds of McPherson Square homeless remain on street, D.C. says
Two-thirds of McPherson Square homeless remain on street, D.C. says
As of Thursday, just two of the more than 70 residents of McPherson Square had been placed in permanent D.C. housing.
www.washingtonpost.com
More Building Won?t Make Housing Affordable
More Building Won’t Make Housing Affordable
America’s housing crisis has reached unfathomable proportions. But new construction isn’t enough to solve it.
newrepublic.com
Why YIMBYs are about to sue the daylights out of cities across the Bay Area
Why YIMBYs are about to sue the daylights out of cities across the Bay Area
Housing advocates are about to deliver a message to the Bay Area: Comply with state…
www.sfchronicle.com
At the heart of Colorado River crisis, the mighty 'Law of the River' holds sway
At the heart of Colorado River crisis, the mighty ‘Law of the River’ holds sway
At the heart of tensions over water allotments from the Colorado River is a complex set of agreements and decrees known as the ‘Law of the River.’
www.latimes.com
Biden restores roadless protection to the Tongass, North America's largest rainforest
Biden restores roadless protection to the Tongass, North America’s largest rainforest
The Tongass National Forest in Alaska, a focus of political battles over old-growth logging and road-building in forests for decades, has received new protection from the Biden administration.
theconversation.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design