• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About
  • RSS Icon

Beard Brook Village: The End Game

March 9, 2019 By Eric Caine 10 Comments

Mickey at Beard Brook

The last days of Beard Brook Village were like the aftermath of a natural disaster— people pawing through the rubble of discarded clothing, bicycle parts and cooking utensils, a stream of humanity pushing shopping carts, baby strollers, and wheel chairs to and fro, and loose dogs everywhere.

The debris-strewn chaos of Beard Brook was in stark contrast to the city’s new encampment, tentatively called Gateway Village, where uniform rows of identical tents spread out on a bluff overlooking the Tuolumne River only a few hundred yards from Beard Brook Park.

But up close, even the military order of the new encampment showed signs of yielding to the persistent entropy of homelessness. Despite applications of wood chips meant to keep the place dry, heavy rains have left pools and mud most everywhere. Seemingly oblivious to constant warnings, many campers have been stacking random belongings outside their tents in violation of one of the new rules for residents.

Nonetheless, in countless ways, the new site has offered many people a vast improvement over Beard Brook Village. Most villagers now have considerably larger tents—the new ones are 10×10—and better security than they did at Beard Brook. There are more coordinated service efforts, and more staff to assist people with special needs.

While many campers were spooked when a chain link fence went up around the new site, the fence has proved helpful in stemming the constant flow of outsiders, opportunists and outlaws that afflicted the Beard Brook site.

Especially for the elderly and infirm, just being on level ground is a vast improvement over the steep slope at Beard Brook. Picnic tables in front of a small trailer at the north end of the camp offer a gathering place where people can share morning coffee and pastries, and the trailer is staffed by outreach workers and volunteers ready to help almost every day.

While city and county authorities have done an outstanding job directing the transition from Beard Brook to Gateway, problems loom. Local spokespeople keep insisting the encampment is temporary and will be taken down by June or August at the latest.

But thus far, the only alternative to camping is a plan to add 180 beds to the nearby Berberian Shelter, run by the Salvation Army. There’s also a proposal to purchase another Salvation Army facility on 7th and I streets in downtown Modesto and use it as transitional lodging for families.

At slightly over 200 more beds, the proposed alternatives to camping will fall far short of accommodating well over 400 people, the peak population at Beard Brook. And that’s not even counting the hundreds who remain downtown, and in streets and parks throughout the city.

Many people have forgotten that Beard Brook Village came to be as the result of a ruling by the Ninth Circuit Court that homeless people could not be prosecuted for sleeping outside if no alternatives were available. Local authorities made a wise decision in allowing people to camp, but have been stymied by the costs and obstacles in the way of more permanent solutions.

There’s also a persistent myth that homelessness will be solved when people get back on their feet and become self-sufficient. Anyone who’s had a close-up view of homelessness realizes the problem does not stem from any single cause, and most especially not from a failure to work.

First and foremost, a very large percentage of homeless people—some say as many as a third—are seriously mentally ill. There’s also a growing population of elderly homeless people whose Social Security incomes haven’t kept pace with housing costs, and another segment whose disability incomes have followed the same trajectory. Hardly any members of these groups will ever work enough to become self-sufficient.

Conventional wisdom attributes homelessness to drug use—the needles!!!—but drug use is often a consequence of homelessness rather than a cause. And until we start treating it as a health problem rather than a character failing, we’ll make no progress on reducing its effects.

The one thing we do know with certainty is that conventional treatments for addiction work with only a small percentage of users, so that’s another segment of the homeless population that isn’t going to be up and on its feet anytime soon.

At Gateway Village

The other stark reality is that in the new economy, work doesn’t necessarily lead to housing. For many in the San Joaquin Valley, $12 an hour is above average pay; no one can find satisfactory living conditions on that sum, especially if they need reliable transportation.

To their great credit, local authorities have managed the manifold problems of sheltering homeless people very well so far. Smart city cops and closely involved county staff people have handled a devilishly difficult situation as humanely and efficiently as anyone could expect, but no one has yet offered a convincing plan for what comes next.

Given the magnitude of the problem, no lasting solutions to homelessness will happen without large infusions of federal and state money, no matter how much we wish otherwise. Meanwhile, many people closest to the problem are agreeing that camping is a better option than a return to the streets.

Absent realistic alternatives, local authorities would be wise to listen. Beard Brook Village may be past history, but for the people who camped there and the many others like them, there’s still no end game.

 

 

 

 

Filed Under: History Tagged With: Beard Brook Park, Beard Brook Village, Homelessness and Poverty in Stanislaus County, Homelessness in Modesto

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Tina Flores says

    March 9, 2019 at 11:16 am

    Thank you for providing a very accurate description of the situation at hand. Despite not having any permanent solutions, I felt that this was very well-written & balanced when discussing causes & those impacted.

    Reply
  2. Cathy heap says

    March 9, 2019 at 11:29 am

    Well it they the city’s would get off they’re ass and help those who are HOUSELESS and give them a place to call home ,the city’s has a lot of vacant building’s and houses that are sitting with no one in them .that would solve the problem .

    Reply
    • AMNF says

      March 11, 2019 at 12:12 am

      “ Give them “ Really? I want to see Someone or Some Agency Give Free Housing? You’re living in La, La, Land if you think that’s EVER going to Happen!

      Reply
    • Debora Tyler says

      March 11, 2019 at 4:26 pm

      Why does the city owe anyone. They have done more than most. After seeing the BBV situation and the aftermath, I for one am tired of the bellyaching. The city, the volunteers who have worked endlessly, donation warriors who have gives beyond all imagination…to what end. A few success stories, wonderful. But mostly things are the same, people are the same. I will tell you what I tell my children and grandchildren…CHOICES CHOICES CHOICES. Every action has a consequence. Sometimes you can help to much. Eveeyone needs to be irresponsible for their choices.

      Reply
  3. Bob says

    March 10, 2019 at 3:59 pm

    First I want to say this is fantastically written and I thank you (Eric) for your balanced representation.Next I want to restate as I have for year’s,we can have a million resources offering help but if their are no houses to rent and regulations to build them are too difficult for builder’s nothing you do is going to be effective,so in short your waisting money.As far as Vacant building to house the homeless,The City and County owns a lot and it only takes a public record’s request to find out how many.Sadly too many people have idealistic solutions that only pacify our community,this is done to create an illusion that they are really helping,but as anyone with eye’s and a brain can see,Homelessness is getting worse not better.My solution would be to fast track building codes,amend land use laws,create incentives for builder’s,work on fare and balanced rental law’s,start building new affordable housing FAST and audit all program’s that are intended to help for their effectiveness and spending,Then and only then might we make a true dent in creating something we as a community we can be proud of.

    Reply
    • frank says

      March 11, 2019 at 5:55 am

      Bob, love your solution ideas, it will take some real changes to the building process as you suggest. I just read this and want to share as it addresses the issue from a different perspective, The Green New Deal: https://www.jacobinmag.com/2019/02/green-new-deal-housing-ocasio-cortez-climate
      Also, about a year ago I investigated the county and city of Modesto owned property and what is vacant is actually very little. The biggest issue, no matter who owns the property, is the NIMBY issue as witnessed by two failed attempts to site a Homeless Low Barrier Shelter.

      Reply
    • Eric Caine says

      March 11, 2019 at 7:31 am

      Thank you Bob. I agree with you and Frank that we need to look harder at obstacles to providing affordable housing. Regulations should provide benefits, not liabilities.

      Reply
  4. Richard Dominguez says

    March 10, 2019 at 5:29 pm

    I’m a down town street team member and live at gateway village I’m on disability a year clean and sober honestly 70% of the population here is in active addiction .If there not willing to address there addiction your enabling them u got to pull weeds . Feed weeds expecting flowers?

    Reply
  5. Babette Nunes Wagner says

    March 11, 2019 at 6:57 am

    Another well written, insightful article Eric (and interesting follow-up comments.) I remember there being a homeless/house-less population in Newman when I grew up in the 50’s 60’s…but they were “ours” to care for when we had spare food, clothing or a chore “for hire” (if they were able.) Some were WWII or Korean vets with PTSD, some were alcoholics (also often an after effect of the war)…. and there was likely even some drug use back then, but the safety net of a County Mental Health facility and County hospital in Modesto kept their numbers low and their health better than one would expect in those conditions. In addition, one of the local lumber companies in town, allowed folks to construct a make-shift Shanty Town on a corner of that property, and as children, we knew several of those sad and lonely people by name and befriended them (as curious kids with no preformed judgments are wont to do.) But with different times, more people unable to work or afford housing (and simply more people in general) as well as both the County Mental and Public hospitals closed, there is no longer a safety net, much less even a system in place to handle the burgeoning problem we are faced with today.. Unfortunately, these poor souls are now dependent, as Blanche Dubois would say, “on the kindness of strangers.” Sadly, like today’s public funded tent housing, that kindness also seems to be in short supply and I see the whole situation as both a heartbreaking and difficult to solve situation with respect to any long term solution given the current environment not only in Modesto, but nationwide.

    The country as a whole has very simply failed the “least among us” including many who served their nation in battle (and may still be carrying the scars of war) in their time of greatest need, be it just a roof over their heads, or the need for hospitalized treatment for the diseases that often go hand in hand with chronic health issues or addiction.

    Reply
    • Eric Caine says

      March 11, 2019 at 7:29 am

      Thank you Babette. I agree that simple arithmetic explains many of our problems with homelessness. If a percentage of the population is seriously mentally ill, and the population grows, the number of mentally ill people grows, And if we stop caring for the mentally ill, we find more mentally ill people are homeless. And so it goes.

      Those of us who’ve had problems and are of a certain age will remember “flophouses,” usually hotels where rooms could be had cheap by the week. The Covell was one in downtown Modesto. Today, people on Social Security or disability can’t find a flophouse; the worst lodging at a roach motel is $60 a night.

      Those who would blame homelessness on failings of moral character refuse to look at the numbers. And I agree also that the “winos” and others in our midst used to have refuge, not just in the form of cheap rooms but in regard to sympathetic government and programs. We’ve become much more mean-spirited since then.

      Reply

Leave a Reply to Babette Nunes Wagner Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Enter Captcha Here : *

Reload Image

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

How the Capitol Riot Thrust Big American Companies Deeper Into Politics
How the Capitol Riot Thrust Big American Companies Deeper Into Politics
“Words alone are not enough.” Corporate moves to halt political funding and decry the forces behind the Jan. 6 riot have accelerated a broader movement in business to address social and political issues.
www.wsj.com
I've hesitated to call Donald Trump a fascist. Until now | Opinion
I’ve hesitated to call Donald Trump a fascist. Until now | Opinion
After last week the label seems not just acceptable, but necessary.
www.newsweek.com
The Cheney-McCarthy rift busts open
The Cheney-McCarthy rift busts open
The Republican leaders’ split on impeachment presages a bigger battle over Trump and the GOP.
www.politico.com
Beaten, sprayed with mace and hit with stun guns: police describe injuries to dozens of officers during assault on U.S. Capitol
Beaten, sprayed with mace and hit with stun guns: police describe injuries to dozens of officers during assault on U.S. Capitol
Authorities say many officers face long recovery following riot
www.washingtonpost.com
Trump Authoritarianism Denial Is Over Now
Trump Authoritarianism Denial Is Over Now
Just weeks, ago, conservatives insisted Trump would concede if he lost the election.
nymag.com
Fact check: Men who stormed Capitol identified by Reuters are not undercover Antifa as posts claim
Fact check: Men who stormed Capitol identified by Reuters are not undercover Antifa as posts claim
Social media users have been sharing content online that suggests those who stormed the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6 were Antifa, not Trump supporters. Many have been using compilations of pictures as purported evidence, but examination of these images shows they do not support…
www.reuters.com
Who Funded the Putsch of January 6, 2021?
Who Funded the Putsch of January 6, 2021?
We must investigate the riots and find out who was behind it, who organized and financed it.
billmoyers.com

Senior Trump Official: “We Were Wrong, He’s a Fascist”

“The legacy of the Trump administration is going to be that the president sparked an insurrection and people died.”
nymag.com
35 times Capitol Police arrested more demonstrators than the 14 insurgents arrested Wednesday
35 times Capitol Police arrested more demonstrators than the 14 insurgents arrested Wednesday
They have arrested more than 3,600 demonstrators since 2016.
www.motherjones.com
Perspective | The pro-Trump media world peddled the lies that fueled the Capitol mob. Fox News led the way.
Perspective | The pro-Trump media world peddled the lies that fueled the Capitol mob. Fox News led the way.
Even today, they are still at it.
www.washingtonpost.com
Joe Scarborough Drops F-Bomb on MSNBC, Calls for Arrest of Donald Trump After Capitol Raid
Joe Scarborough Drops F-Bomb on MSNBC, Calls for Arrest of Donald Trump After Capitol Raid
“If they are not arrested and brought to justice today, then we are no longer a nation of laws and we only tell people they can do this again,”
Morning Joe host says, referring to the…
www.rollingstone.com
Here's What Trump Said Right Before His Supporters Stormed The Capitol
Here’s What Trump Said Right Before His Supporters Stormed The Capitol
Just moments before hundreds of his supporters stormed the Capitol and interrupted a step in the peaceful transfer of power…
talkingpointsmemo.com
Opinion | Hawley, Cruz and their Senate cohort are the Constitution’s most dangerous domestic enemies
Opinion | Hawley, Cruz and their Senate cohort are the Constitution’s most dangerous domestic enemies
This political grandstanding is a violation of their oath of office.
www.washingtonpost.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design