• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About
  • RSS Icon

Down and Dirty Water Wars: Part IV

December 8, 2016 By Eric Caine Leave a Comment

San Joaquin Kit Fox, by California Department of Fish and Wildlife
San Joaquin Kit Fox, by California Department of Fish and Wildlife

Mainstream media, especially newspapers, have an obligation to avoid the twin evils of misinformation and fake news, even on the opinion pages. This doesn’t mean we should expect OP/ED contributions to be free from bias, hysteria, hyperbole, name-calling, invective and other traditional tools of political discourse. Distortions though they are, these are long-accustomed elements of our free-speech heritage.

But particularly in places where there is only one mainstream news source, that source should avoid spreading falsehoods, even when under the heading of “opinion” and especially when from what appear to be qualified sources.

Unfortunately, both the Fresno Bee and Modesto Bee recently broke this rule when they published, “Federal water for tiny fish leaves other species high and dry.” The author, Tony Francois, is an attorney for the Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF), “the first and oldest conservative/libertarian public law firm in the United States.”

All well and good. Nothing inherently wrong with attorneys, conservatives, or libertarians.

But despite his credentials, which suggest he should know better, Mr. Francois is apparently not just ill-informed but misinformed both about water and endangered species, two subjects supposedly within the PLF range of expertise.

Consider the following thesis, the spine of his argument against policies he says are favored by the Bureau of Reclamation and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service:

“….in order to waste the Valley’s federal water supply on the smelt, federal bureaucrats have diverted that water from several other species of endangered wildlife in the Valley: the California tiger salamander, the kit fox, various species of fairy shrimp and even the iconic California condor.

These species all share two things in common: They rely on San Joaquin Valley irrigated farms for food, water, shelter and habitat, and the Fish and Wildlife Service is supposed to protect them in the same way it is supposed to protect the Delta smelt.”

Okay, there’s a least one supportable factual claim here. It’s where Francois says the Fish and Wildlife service is supposed to protect other endangered species, “the same way it is supposed to protect the Delta smelt.”

Carrizo Plain, Bureau of Land Management
Carrizo Plain, Bureau of Land Management

The stuff about condors, salamanders, kit foxes and fairy shrimp? Purest nonsense, or even worse than nonsense—it’s misinformation. None of these creatures, “rely on San Joaquin Valley irrigated farms for food, water, shelter and habitat.” In fact, in every case, irrigated agriculture is inhospitable to the species cited.

Condors, as befitting a raptor that forages in desert-like habitat, get most all their water from the large mammalian carcasses they prefer to feed on. They need long “runways” to take off from, especially after feeding. Row crops, vineyards, and orchards are not only free of carcasses, they provide no takeoff opportunities. Condors nest in caves in the Sierra and Coast Range, not in the Valley.*

Like condors, kit foxes prefer open rangeland and arid landscapes like the Carrizo Plain. They eat the small rodents that farmers tend to eliminate with poisons that are also often lethal to the foxes.

Contrary to Francois’s claims they depend on irrigated agriculture, tiger salamanders and fairy shrimp depend on vernal pool habitat that has been decimated by irrigated agriculture. In fact, in every case, the elimination of rangeland by nut orchards, vineyards, and row crops has reduced habitat for these threatened species, condors and kit fox included.

It’s possible Mr. Francois’s zeal as an advocate has shaded his understanding of issues he should have studied more closely. But McClatchy newspapers have no excuse, and in fact have a long and proud tradition of delivering reliable news. Readers of the Modesto and Fresno Bee expect the best from the only mainstream newspaper in town. Bee editors owe them a correction and apology.

*There are a few records of condors nesting in cavities in the trunks of very large trees like the Sequoia redwood.

 

 

Filed Under: Environment, Featured Tagged With: San Joaquin rivers increased flows, San Joaquin Valley endangered species, San Joaquin Valley rivers

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

A South Texan?s Wild, Life-affirming Quest to Break a National Birding Record
A South Texan’s Wild, Life-affirming Quest to Break a National Birding Record
When she began her year-long bird-spotting adventure, Tiffany Kersten was lost and lonely. She ended up achieving a major milestone and finding her way.
www.texasmonthly.com
Ron Johnson tried to hand fake elector info to Mike Pence on Jan. 6, panel reveals
Ron Johnson tried to hand fake elector info to Mike Pence on Jan. 6, panel reveals
A top aide said the Wisconsin Republican senator wanted to give Pence the list of pro-Trump electors as he prepared to certify the 2020 election.
www.politico.com
Raffensperger says he wishes Fox News carried every Jan. 6 hearing
Raffensperger says he wishes Fox News carried every Jan. 6 hearing
“I think it would have helped our party heal, given [people] more facts.”
www.axios.com
'Not safe anymore': Portland confronts the limits of its support for homeless services
‘Not safe anymore’: Portland confronts the limits of its support for homeless services
Homeless encampments now spill well beyond Portland’s downtown core, dividing a city that has invested liberally in support services.
www.latimes.com
Republicans Will Do It Again
Republicans Will Do It Again
They have not been chastened by the revelations of the January 6 committee.
nymag.com
Birdman
Birdman
Bird Brother: A Falconer’s Journey and the Healing Power of Wildlife
www.earthisland.org
The Potato Roll Empire Bankrolling Christian Nationalist Doug Mastriano
The Potato Roll Empire Bankrolling Christian Nationalist Doug Mastriano
The Martins were bit players in politics, until they put Doug Mastriano one step away from becoming Pennsylvania’s next governor.
nymag.com
Roger Stone and Michael Flynn under fire over rallies ‘distorting Christianity’
Roger Stone and Michael Flynn under fire over rallies ‘distorting Christianity’
Prominent Christian leaders accuse Trump allies of spreading misinformation about election and Covid, while distorting Christian teachings at ReAwaken America events
www.theguardian.com
Major water cutbacks loom as shrinking Colorado River nears 'moment of reckoning'
Major water cutbacks loom as shrinking Colorado River nears ‘moment of reckoning’
As the Colorado River water shortage worsens, major cutbacks are needed to reduce most perilous risks, a federal official tells senators.
www.latimes.com
Trump Scammed Supporters Out of $250 Million for Nonexistent Fraud Fund
Trump Scammed Supporters Out of $250 Million for Nonexistent Fraud Fund
Supporters who thought they were donating to “election integrity” instead saw some of their money funneled to Trump hotels
www.rollingstone.com
Police Arrested 31 White Supremacists Crammed Into a U-Haul With a Detailed Riot Plan
Police Arrested 31 White Supremacists Crammed Into a U-Haul With a Detailed Riot Plan
Members of the Patriot Front were allegedly planning to disrupt a pride parade in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho.
www.vice.com
Dishonor, Trump’s and His Party’s, Is the Real January 6th Takeaway
Dishonor, Trump’s and His Party’s, Is the Real January 6th Takeaway
Liz Cheney, defying the G.O.P., offered a searing indictment of the former President at Thursday’s hearing.
www.newyorker.com
Trumpworld Lied To Your Face About The Election
Trumpworld Lied To Your Face About The Election
In the fall and winter of 2020, former President Trump’s top lieutenants…
talkingpointsmemo.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design