• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Pursuing truth toward justice

The Valley Citizen

Pursuing truth toward justice
  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About

Dr. Kennedy on (ground)Water Subsidies

December 8, 2015 By Vance Kennedy 1 Comment

Dr. Vance Kennedy
Dr. Vance Kennedy

Dr. Vance Kennedy is an award-winning scientist who had a distinguished career at the U.S. Geological Survey. Though long-retired, he follows current water issues closely and has become very concerned that the rush to conserve water via drip irrigation ignores the recharge benefits of flood irrigation, especially in those areas with highly permeable soil of the kind typical near Modesto.  Here, he takes exception to a recent article in the Modesto Bee.

Recently, the Modesto Bee estimated that the Modesto Irrigation District (MID) has been subsidizing farmers who use flood irrigation by about $100 million dollars over an unspecified period of time. The figure is a gross misrepresentation.

Over the last ten years, total value of farm production in Stanislaus County was a little over $28 billion, and over twenty years, about $42 billion. Let’s assume twenty percent of production used MID water, or $5.6 billion for ten years and $8.4 billion for twenty years.

That crop production is often estimated to stimulate three times as much economic activity locally as its initial value. Hence, farm production dependent on MID water may have caused as much as $16+ billion over ten years or $25 billion over twenty years. Not bad! So the return on investment on $100 million for ten years was 160 times and for twenty years it was 250 times! And there were other benefits.

We need to remember that groundwater is our ONLY reliable source of water during prolonged droughts. Hence, it really is priceless. Second, in a 2004 report by the U.S. Geological Survey, it was estimated (and it was only an estimate) that almost sixty percent of groundwater recharge in the Modesto area was from flood irrigation by local farmers. Given these figures, it is imperative local farmers continue flood irrigating for the benefit of everyone, despite the increasing popularity of drip irrigation, which depletes ground water rather than recharging it.

Prior to 1994, Modesto depended solely on groundwater for all its water needs. Thereafter, the city obtained about half its supply from surface water, the other half from groundwater. During the current drought, groundwater usage is up and will increase even more if this El Nino doesn’t help dramatically. It follows that the city of Modesto should be encouraging farmers to flood irrigate, and that includes keeping the cost of irrigation water very low.

Vertical permeability of soil and rocks in the Modesto area ranges widely. In order to recharge groundwater, one needs large areas of permeable soils and appropriate flooding, which farmers have provided in the past. A major reason for that flooding was the water was very low cost. Where feasible, the city, county, and irrigation districts should also maintain large settling basins to recharge groundwater when surface water is available.

When farmers are accused of not paying their fair share for water, many factors have been left out of the cost equation, including how much of flood irrigation is lost to evaporation and transpiration. The amount of water that moves below the root zone and recharges groundwater is available for use by others than farmers, including cities and industries, at very little cost. The cost to the farmer to maintain equipment and labor to apply irrigation water has been ignored, but shouldn’t be.

It seems reasonable that the entities that benefit from flood irrigating should bear the costs of these benefits. Farmers benefit from water to support their crops, and cities and others benefit from the recharge to groundwater. It is their insurance during prolonged droughts.

In the past, that insurance benefit has been paid by a surcharge on electric bills (the so-called subsidy referred to by the Bee) which everyone pays. The Bee continues to ignore the value of farmer-supplied groundwater, which is used by everyone in addition to farmers. It also ignores the insurance value of that groundwater in times of drought.

A key point is that, to the extent that flood irrigation rates increase, it will encourage more and more drip irrigation, thereby depleting groundwater and reducing immensely valuable groundwater storage. That can be a recipe for future disaster with global warming and it will happen long after present politicians are gone. The adage, “There is no free lunch (or water)” is highly appropriate.

With global warming, there will be less snow in the mountains to maintain late spring and early summer runoff. Heavier rains are expected due to warmer oceans. Only limited amounts of such heavy rains can be stored in a short time. Population growth in the Valley will increase water demand, and farmland providing groundwater recharge will be paved over.

There is an urgent need to consider what the population carrying capacity is for the Valley under major climate change. We are no longer in a frontier situation. Prolonged droughts are a real possibility and should be planned for.

If we are to encourage groundwater recharge, we need to have a better understanding of the hydrology of groundwater recharge and the interaction between surface water and groundwater. That means measuring, to the extent feasible, the movement of water below and above ground.  That will require money and new technology.

Water is going to cost much more for everyone and groundwater economics is now a focus for discussions of water in general. The distribution of costs must reflect actual costs and benefits in toto, and that can only happen with much better hydrologic understanding and acceptance of the extremely valuable role flood irrigation plays in providing water for the whole community.

 

Filed Under: Environment, Featured Tagged With: Modesto groundwater, Modesto Irrigation District electricity rates

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Chris Gulick says

    December 11, 2015 at 9:01 pm

    I’m having a tough time buying in to Mr. Kennedy’s conclusions.
    He seems to be basing his logic on the idea that the citizens of Modesto are THE big consumer of ground water when it seems pretty obvious that is highly unlikely to be the case.
    I say highly unlikely rather than giving a more definitive answer only because agricultural wells are not quantatatively measured.
    Until they are this discussion is kinda’ pointless.

    Just for the sake of discussion, if we use consumption of “developed” surface water as a guide where Ag uses 80% and everyone else combined uses 20 % then it would only stand to reason that a similar split would apply to ground water.
    So any benefit from flood irrigation BY farmers is quickly consumed BY farmers.
    To directly quote Vance :
    “It seems reasonable that the entities that benefit from flood irrigating should bear the costs of these benefits.”
    I’m right there with you Vance.
    Let’s just cut to the chase, farmers don’t strive to “conserve” water.
    A farmers primary goal is to increase the “efficiency” of water’s use to maximize profit.
    Any water “conserved” is merely repurposed either in increased acreage or in planting more water intensive, higher value crops.
    What else explains the current trend in crop choices that favors almonds ?
    What say before we start handing out MORE taxpayer provided subsidies we meter EVERY well and figure out who’s using how much, where and when.
    Until we do, organized ground water recharge is futile and a waste of taxpayer dollars.

    There is a simple reason the agricultural industry continues to adamantly oppose metering and reporting ground water use.

    It ain’t brain surgery.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

Gimme Shelter: Mayor Karen Bass on homelessness and the California housing crisis
Gimme Shelter: Mayor Karen Bass on homelessness and the California housing crisis
Liam Dillon and Ben Oreskes of the L.A. Times interview Mayor Karen Bass about homelessness and housing problems in California.
calmatters.org
Judge Luttig Has a Warning for America
Judge Luttig Has a Warning for America
Our democracy is “under vicious, unsustainable, and unendurable attack” from within…
morningshots.thebulwark.com
Rupert Murdoch has fuelled polarisation of society, Barack Obama says
Rupert Murdoch has fuelled polarisation of society, Barack Obama says
Former US president tells Sydney audience that media coverage has helped exacerbate divisions and that we no longer have a “shared story”
www.theguardian.com
California faces catastrophic flood dangers ? and a need to invest billions in protection
California faces catastrophic flood dangers and a need to invest billions in protection
A new state plan for the Central Valley calls for spending as much as $30 billion over 30 years to prepare for the dangers.
www.latimes.com
Oakland will get millions for the ?inhumane? crisis at one huge homeless encampment. Officials say it?s not enough
Oakland will get millions for the “inhumane” crisis at one huge homeless encampment. Officials say it’s not enough
Gavin Newsom’s administration has awarded Oakland a $4.7 million grant to come up with…
www.sfchronicle.com
Alaska?s Fisheries Are Collapsing. This Congresswoman Is Taking on the Industry She Says Is to Blame.
Alaska’s Fisheries Are Collapsing. This Congresswoman Is Taking on the Industry She Says Is to Blame.
Mary Peltola won her election by campaigning on a platform to save the state’s prized fisheries. A powerful fishing lobby is standing in her way.
www.politico.com
Jimmy Carter's final foe: A parasitic worm that preyed on millions in Africa and Asia
Jimmy Carter’s final foe: A parasitic worm that preyed on millions in Africa and Asia
One of former President Carter’s biggest hopes is wiping out an infectious parasitic disease that’s plagued humans for millennia. How close is he?
www.latimes.com
Climate Extremes Threaten California?s Central Valley Songbirds - Eos
Climate Extremes Threaten California’s Central Valley Songbirds – Eos
A “nestbox highway” in California’s Central Valley is guiding songbirds to safe nesting sites and giving scientists a peek at fledgling success in a changing climate.
eos.org
Alaska Republican touts benefits of children being abused to death
Alaska Republican touts benefits of children being abused to death
Republican David Eastman suggested the death of child abuse victims could be a “cost savings” to wider society.
www.newsweek.com
Editorial: Newsom's drought order amid wet winter threatens iconic California species
Editorial: Newsom’s drought order amid wet winter threatens iconic California species
Gov. Gavin Newsom has effectively ended environmental regulations protecting California rivers and migratory fish by extending drought-year waivers.
www.latimes.com
Two-thirds of McPherson Square homeless remain on street, D.C. says
Two-thirds of McPherson Square homeless remain on street, D.C. says
As of Thursday, just two of the more than 70 residents of McPherson Square had been placed in permanent D.C. housing.
www.washingtonpost.com
More Building Won?t Make Housing Affordable
More Building Won’t Make Housing Affordable
America’s housing crisis has reached unfathomable proportions. But new construction isn’t enough to solve it.
newrepublic.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design