• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • About The Valley Citizen

Homeless: It’s going to get worse

May 24, 2019 By Eric Caine 3 Comments

Kenneth “Pops” Yarber

Every year, the community Continuum of Care (COC) does a Point-in-Time (PIT) count of homeless people throughout California. Thus far this year, 9 of the 13 most populous regions have reported. Of those 9, 8 regions counted more homeless people than last year.

Conducted last January, the Stanislaus County count set a record of 1,923 people; the previous high of 1,800 people was in 2009, during the Great Recession. Still, for the vast majority of people, the stark realities of homelessness have yet to sink in.

For many, homeless people have only themselves to blame—they’re homeless by choice—a notion that was popularized when Ronald Reagan argued that homeless people were not victims of economic policies, but, “They make it their own choice for staying out there.”

But even during the Reagan era, there was ample evidence that rising housing costs were a significant factor in homelessness. An article in the New York Times as far back as 1988 noted that, “For many, the fundamental problem is economic: housing costs that have risen beyond the means of people with menial jobs.”

Thirty years later, anyone with even a passing regard for facts has to acknowledge that housing costs are the major driver of homelessness and poverty, especially in California. The Bay Area is a prime example; just consider its red-hot economy.

Last April, the Bay Area added 13,000 jobs. This was on top of 9,600 in January, 9,900 in February, and 12,500 in March. For those who think jobs are the answer to homelessness, the Bay Area would seem to offer the ideal solution. In fact, homelessness is reaching all-time highs in the Bay Area, with no end in sight.

The same apparent paradox plagues virtually the entire state. After years of a boom driven by increasing demand for almonds, pistachios and walnuts, the San Joaquin Valley remains an epicenter for rising homelessness and poverty. It’s also a destination for Bay Area workers priced out of the housing market. The result is a ripple effect that escalates housing prices in the Valley and contributes to increased homelessness.

Aside from the prevalent notion that hundreds of thousands of people woke up one morning and “chose” to be homeless, other explanations for homelessness invariably include Democrats blaming Republicans and Republicans blaming Democrats. But homelessness isn’t difficult to understand.

In any given population of human beings, a certain percentage is mentally ill. If in the past we institutionalized the mentally ill and then chose to release them, we might expect mentally ill people to appear on our streets—and that’s what happened when we de-institutionalized the mentally ill in the seventies and eighties. Most authorities on homelessness estimate at least 25% of homeless people are seriously mentally ill; that figure does not include people with less severe but still significant mental disorders.

We also might expect an increase in homeless people if compensation for disability remained static while housing costs spiraled upwards. That’s what happened, and that’s why people like Kenneth “Pops” Yarber and Cathy Heap and her husband ended up on the streets or living in their cars, despite receiving disability payments.

Most anyone would agree that if wages stagnated and living costs soared upward, we could expect a rise in homelessness. Over the last few decades, we’ve seen the cost of living soar exponentially in our major cities and wages stagnate for workers without college degrees, some two-thirds of the labor force.

Once we understand the realities of income for workers without a college education, the Bay Area paradox of rising numbers of homeless people in a growing economy is easily understood. A janitor moving from the Deep South to Santa Clara County in 1960 could expect an increase of 107% in income after housing costs; that same janitor today would lose income after housing costs.

Modesto Outdoor Emergency Shelter

For decades, Democrats and Republicans have exulted about the new tech economy and the rise of “knowledge workers” with college educations. But college costs since the 1980s have risen almost eight times faster than wages—yet another data point that explains why working people have trouble moving into the ranks of those with higher incomes. And even today’s college graduates are finding it harder and harder to escape the massive debt incurred while finishing a bachelor’s degree.

Some argue that the chief cause of homelessness is drugs. It’s certainly true that many homeless people use drugs of one kind or another, including alcohol. One study shows as many as 35 percent of homeless Americans are negatively affected by substance abuse.

But far more homeowners and renters use drugs than homeless people; the difference again is income. Retired professional football players addicted to opioids sometimes consume as many 200 painkillers a day, a prodigious number that would kill most people. But as long as they can afford the pills, they’re not homeless.

Recent reports that homeless numbers have spiked in Utah have encouraged critics to argue the state’s pioneering Housing First program failed. In fact, Utah’s increasing count of homeless people is due to the same factors as California’s increases: when the Housing First program ran out of money and places to put people, rising housing costs led to, “a deficit of over 47,000 units for its poorest residents.”

Despite ample evidence to the contrary, many local authorities continue to deny that real solutions for homelessness will require money enough to shelter not just the current numbers of people who need it, but the many more to come. In fact, so-called “temporary shelters” like Modesto’s Outdoor Emergency Shelter, which features over 300 tents, are very likely the best and only solution for the near future because it’s going to take years before sufficient affordable housing can be provided.

Cathy Heap

Meanwhile, veteran observers of homelessness like Utah’s Glenn Bailey, who runs a Salt Lake City food pantry, offer the most realistic takes on homelessness:

“As long as people drink water, you’re going to have to figure out a way to supply it. As long as our economic system creates homelessness, we’re going to have to figure out a way to respond,” he said last January.

Those who think a booming economy will be enough to pull us out of the crisis of homelessness should consider carefully the implications of the United Way’s ongoing study of poverty in California, which offers more inconvenient but undeniable facts:

1 in 3 Households Struggle: More than one in three California households (33%) do not earn sufficient income to meet basic needs.

Working hard, but not earning enough: Of the estimated 3.3 million households in California that fall below the Real Cost Measure [a measure of poverty], 9 in 10 have at least one working adult (when you control for households led by seniors and people with disabilities).

With no end in sight to rising housing costs, income disparities, and political resistance to hard facts and cold truths, there is one sure thing we can conclude from the current state of the homeless crisis—it’s going to get worse.

 

 

Filed Under: History Tagged With: Homelessness and Poverty in Stanislaus County, Homelessness in Modesto, Homelessness in Stanislaus County, San Joaquin Valley homeless

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Mary Brown says

    May 24, 2019 at 4:02 pm

    I read an article recently about Bay Area homelessness; about a Bay Area college professor living out of her car in SF….yes, a college professor. Now in Mountain View, the city council wants to outlaw street parking for vans, trucks, rv’s ; anyone living out of a vehicle,. The criteria would be any vehicle over 6-7 ft high. Let them do it; they won’t have service workers, retail, restaurants and others and the economy would collapse.

    Reply
  2. Al Lucchesi says

    May 25, 2019 at 3:13 am

    My wife and I are seniors and we feel lucky and blessed to now have a home. This could end with one sad event like natural disaster like an earthquake or a fire. There is something wrong in California and the Bay Area and the USA were I see bare hills that could be filled with needed affordable housing, one example is drive along 680 South to North and there many places that many affordable housing could be built but as I understand the zoning laws will not allow building in that area.. This is perfect example of capitalism not being the economic tool for the housing problem./ Something went wrong and those that know what went wrong will say what went wrong.

    Reply
  3. Ken hansen says

    May 25, 2019 at 10:01 am

    Tenements would work in Stanislaus Co because there are not enough high income earners to drive up costs by converting them into upscale apartments…that is not the case in the Bay Area. And that is why there aren’t any.

    There are, no doubt, many investors in this area that would fund tenement construction if a decent rate of return could be guaranteed…say 10% vs the measly APR offered by banks.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Enter Captcha Here : *

Reload Image

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

New Trump rule could eliminate food stamps for almost 200,000 Californians | CalMatters
New Trump rule could eliminate food stamps for almost 200,000 Californians | CalMatters
The rule is the first of three Trump-era food stamp cuts to be finalized. Under all three, roughly 3.7 million Americans, including 625,700 Californians, could lose assistance in buying groceries.
calmatters.org
Mercury-Laden Fog May Be Poisoning California?s Mountain Lions
Mercury-Laden Fog May Be Poisoning California’s Mountain Lions
A new study has found that pumas in the Santa Cruz Mountains display higher mercury levels than big cats in inland regions
www.smithsonianmag.com
False Idol -- Why the Christian Right Worships Donald Trump
False Idol — Why the Christian Right Worships Donald Trump
www.rollingstone.com
Income for poorest Americans fell faster than previously thought: study
Income for poorest Americans fell faster than previously thought: study
thehill.com
California to Subsidize Growers’ Labor Camps | Community Alliance
California to Subsidize Growers’ Labor Camps | Community Alliance
By David Bacon (Editor’s note: Reprinted with permission. Originally appeared in Capital and Main, Oct. 4, 2019.) In California, many farmworkers can’t find decent places to live, or even any place at all. When the grape harvest starts in Coachella Valley, families of pickers bed down in the Mecca supermarket parking lot. In Sonoma County ?
fresnoalliance.com
Perspective | I was a drug rep. I know how pharma companies pushed opioids.
Perspective | I was a drug rep. I know how pharma companies pushed opioids.
Wining and dining aside, it’s all about building trust with doctors
www.washingtonpost.com
The One State Taking a Big Run at Health Reform
The One State Taking a Big Run at Health Reform
Washington state just passed the country’s first public option plan, and its difficult birth carries a warning for national reformers.
www.politico.com
One of L.A.?s most powerful politicians is searching for his homeless son ? cameras in tow
One of L.A.’s most powerful politicians is searching for his homeless son, cameras in tow
Herb Wesson, who is running for L.A. County supervisor, has a new campaign ad in which he is seen searching skid row for his homeless son, Doug.
www.latimes.com
This Doctors Group Is Owned by a Private Equity Firm and Repeatedly Sued the Poor Until We Called Them ? ProPublica
This Doctor’s Group Is Owned by a Private Equity Firm and Repeatedly Sued the Poor Until We Called Them: ProPublica
After the Blackstone Group acquired one of the nation’s largest physician staffing firms in 2017, low-income patients faced far more aggressive debt collection lawsuits. They only stopped after ProPublica and MLK50 asked about it.
www.propublica.org
Cut Greenhouse Gases Immediately or Face Catastrophe, New UN Report Warns
Cut Greenhouse Gases Immediately or Face Catastrophe, New UN Report Warns
The Emissions Gap Report released by the UN Environment Program found that four years after countries signed the Paris agreement and vowed to curtail emissions to stop the worst effects of global warming, countries have ignored the warnings of scientists and continued to expand their carbon footprin…
www.ecowatch.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2019 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design