• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About
  • RSS Icon

Inside The Modesto City Council: City Employees and CalPERS, by Bruce Frohman

January 24, 2013 By Eric Caine Leave a Comment

pension fundNews item from the Modesto Bee: Cost for the City of Modesto to leave CalPERS: $1 Billion plus. 

A Rosy Prediction of Early Last Decade

In the early 2000’s, the Modesto City Council reviewed an analysis of the fiscal integrity of the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, otherwise known as CalPERS. The presentation was made in the context of proposals to lower the retirement age of public employees and/or raise future benefits.

The analysis revealed that CalPERS was flush with cash and would always have plenty of money to pay benefits. The picture was so rosy that it appeared that public employee benefits could be increased without ever increasing the cost to taxpayers.

The net effect of the presentation on the Modesto City Council at the time was to allay any concerns about CalPERS ever having financial problems or that the city would ever have to pony up extra funds to bail out the system. In its wisdom at the time, the Council did NOT opt to reduce the retirement age or up the benefits package of its classified employees. The Council felt that the city’s existing retirement package was competitive and fair. Raising the benefit was considered unfair to the taxpayers.

In 2008, the stock market crash revealed that CalPERS was vulnerable to adverse investment conditions. Suddenly, the retirement program’s funding weaknesses became apparent.

Given the rosy outlook presented before the crash, imagine the shock the City Council of 10 years ago would experience if it had known that by 2013, the City Council would explore the cost of leaving the CalPERS system!

Based on Modesto’s experience with CalPERS, one wonders how many other communities used the early 2000’s rosy information from CalPERS to increase taxpayer costs for employee pensions. It’s easy to see how the increased pension liability combined with shrinking tax revenue created catastrophic budget situations throughout the state.

Hindsight is always 100 percent correct. But along the way, simple decisions based on faulty assumptions can result in catastrophic results years later.

Modesto Has Choices Regarding Its Commitment to CalPERS

In 2013, Modesto could choose to leave CalPERS–if it were willing to pony up over a billion dollars. This clearly won’t happen.

In order to reduce costs, Modesto can either reduce the CalPERS pension package for new hires or put new hires entirely into the Social Security program. Another option would be to offer Social Security and have a CalPERS component that is smaller than the current commitment.

For current employees, the Modesto City Council can make changes, but would be wise to do so by including the input of affected employees who would have to live with a revised system.

A Draconian Proposal

The Modesto City Council is considering a proposal to cut the city’s contribution to CalPERS and require employees to pay entirely for their own pension program. Such a draconian policy is rare in the public and private sectors. For example, under Social Security Law, employers as well as employees pay taxes to help fund the program. If the City Council required employees to fund all of their CalPERS contributions, city employees would have the worst deal in the entire country. The law requires that all employees either contribute to Social Security or participate in a comparable pension plan. Only public employers who previously opted out of Social Security have the choice to stay out of Social Security.

Making employees pay the entire cost of their pension plan would make future hiring very difficult and would cause a migration of current employees to other jobs elsewhere. During a recession, when jobs are scarce, employees can be preyed upon. In the long run, the community would suffer from the loss of employees with vital institutional experience.

Reducing the employer contribution CalPERS to save taxpayer money would have an effect similar to a pay cut. While such a proposal is not as draconian as paying nothing, the result would make Modesto less competitive in the labor market. Modesto city government has highly skilled employees whose worth should be accurately valued and compensated.

Filed Under: Featured, Politics Tagged With: Modesto city employees CalPERs, Modesto city employees pension

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

Warren: Voters Must Elect Dems In Midterms Who Would Nix Filibuster To Codify Roe
Warren: Voters Must Elect Dems In Midterms Who Would Nix Filibuster To Codify Roe
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) on Sunday said she views the midterm elections…
talkingpointsmemo.com
A Farmer’s Quest to Beat California’s Waves of Drought and Deluge
A Farmer’s Quest to Beat California’s Waves of Drought and Deluge
Don Cameron went all in on a trickle-down survival tactic. It could help save America’s agricultural heartland—even if he doesn’t survive the new water war.
www.wired.com
Ten Ways Billionaires Avoid Taxes On An Epic Scale
Ten Ways Billionaires Avoid Taxes On An Epic Scale
This article first appeared at ProPublica. ProPublica is a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative…
talkingpointsmemo.com
A South Texan?s Wild, Life-affirming Quest to Break a National Birding Record
A South Texan’s Wild, Life-affirming Quest to Break a National Birding Record
When she began her year-long bird-spotting adventure, Tiffany Kersten was lost and lonely. She ended up achieving a major milestone and finding her way.
www.texasmonthly.com
Ron Johnson tried to hand fake elector info to Mike Pence on Jan. 6, panel reveals
Ron Johnson tried to hand fake elector info to Mike Pence on Jan. 6, panel reveals
A top aide said the Wisconsin Republican senator wanted to give Pence the list of pro-Trump electors as he prepared to certify the 2020 election.
www.politico.com
Raffensperger says he wishes Fox News carried every Jan. 6 hearing
Raffensperger says he wishes Fox News carried every Jan. 6 hearing
“I think it would have helped our party heal, given [people] more facts.”
www.axios.com
'Not safe anymore': Portland confronts the limits of its support for homeless services
‘Not safe anymore’: Portland confronts the limits of its support for homeless services
Homeless encampments now spill well beyond Portland’s downtown core, dividing a city that has invested liberally in support services.
www.latimes.com
Republicans Will Do It Again
Republicans Will Do It Again
They have not been chastened by the revelations of the January 6 committee.
nymag.com
Birdman
Birdman
Bird Brother: A Falconer’s Journey and the Healing Power of Wildlife
www.earthisland.org
The Potato Roll Empire Bankrolling Christian Nationalist Doug Mastriano
The Potato Roll Empire Bankrolling Christian Nationalist Doug Mastriano
The Martins were bit players in politics, until they put Doug Mastriano one step away from becoming Pennsylvania’s next governor.
nymag.com
Roger Stone and Michael Flynn under fire over rallies ‘distorting Christianity’
Roger Stone and Michael Flynn under fire over rallies ‘distorting Christianity’
Prominent Christian leaders accuse Trump allies of spreading misinformation about election and Covid, while distorting Christian teachings at ReAwaken America events
www.theguardian.com
Major water cutbacks loom as shrinking Colorado River nears 'moment of reckoning'
Major water cutbacks loom as shrinking Colorado River nears ‘moment of reckoning’
As the Colorado River water shortage worsens, major cutbacks are needed to reduce most perilous risks, a federal official tells senators.
www.latimes.com
Trump Scammed Supporters Out of $250 Million for Nonexistent Fraud Fund
Trump Scammed Supporters Out of $250 Million for Nonexistent Fraud Fund
Supporters who thought they were donating to “election integrity” instead saw some of their money funneled to Trump hotels
www.rollingstone.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design