• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About
  • RSS Icon

Is the MID Taxing Customers Illegally with the “Falling Water Charge”?

October 12, 2012 By Eric Caine 2 Comments

 

Falling Water?

Just when it looked like things couldn’t get any worse for the Modesto Irrigation District (MID), the heavens opened and delivered a world of trouble in falling water.

In the arcane parlance of irrigation districts, “falling water” is water that falls from dams and spillways to provide electricity. Some districts impose on their customers a “Falling Water Charge.” The Falling Water Charge is an attempt to capture the value of the falling water and then pass it on as a cost to customers of the district.

The Falling Water Charge as imposed by the MID features two important elements: (1) The Falling Water Charge is hidden in customers’ electrical bills; most customers are not aware of its amount and purpose, and (2) even though the Falling Water charge is paid by MID electrical customers, it is used to cover operational expenses for the district’s Irrigation Division. Thus, MID customers, most unknowingly, subsidize Irrigation Division customers.

On November 2, 2010, California voters approved Proposition 26, also known as, “The Stop Hidden Taxes Initiative.”  One of the consequences of Proposition 26 was to shine a light on practices like the Falling Water Charge. The key issue is whether or not such charges constitute an illegal tax under the definition established by Proposition 26.

Several criteria are used to determine whether or not a fee or charge is in reality a tax as defined by the new law. One key element requires the local government entity, the MID in this case, to show that the fee or charge is not in excess of the amount required for the activity used to justify the charge. Since the Falling Water Charge provides revenue to the Irrigation Division of the MID, MID will have to show how the Charge applies to irrigation costs and whether or not it exceeds those costs.

Costs associated with the Falling Water Charge fluctuate wildly. According to an internal MID memo, they were as high as $10,158,720 and as low as $2,268,371 between 1996 and 2011. The reason for the wide gap between the two figures is doubtless readily available, but now MID will have to offer a public explanation.

Moreover, if a court were to rule the Falling Water Charge is indeed an illegal tax, the MID would lose an important source of revenue. Since the MID has significant financial deficits, the loss of revenue would be a major blow, especially coming after the defeat of a water sale which would have helped the MID begin to recover from some of its losses.

The Falling Water Charge has been in effect since 1995. Once it becomes public knowledge, there are bound to be some angry rate payers. And angry rate payers may be the best the MID can hope for, because if the MID must give up Falling Water Charge revenue, the alternative is higher rates and even more outrage and public scrutiny. For an institution that’s just endured months of scathing public criticism, the prospect of even more to come can’t be appealing.

All in all, MID Directors and management seem in for yet another round of storm and discord, and it’s hard to see how they can emerge with anything but more problems. Next: The Memo From Hell

Filed Under: Featured, History Tagged With: Falling Water Charge, MID Falling Water Charge, Modesto Irrigation District

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Eric Reimer says

    October 12, 2012 at 5:59 pm

    It seems appropriate that the MID cease subsidies of the Irrigation Div. by the Electric Div.; even Directee Wild (whose area of representation contains the majority of the electric customers) is on record as opposing subsidies.

    Would the irrigation users pay more? Of course. Unfair? Not at all.
    In the Oct 2012 MID bill insert there is to be found this statement
    “MID is a not-for-profit organization. All charges are based on cost of service, not making a profit.”

    There is a caveat; historically the MID established electric service as a means of reducing the cost of irrigation water, and if a transfer is to continue in any amount, it must be a clearly stated budget line item, voted on by the Board in open session, and shown as an individual charge on electric bills.

    Reply
  2. Chris Gulick says

    October 12, 2012 at 6:53 pm

    Having faithfully paid my MID bill for the entire time this subsidy has been imposed I can imagine any number of customers would be outraged and looking for a refund or perhaps a class action lawsuit.
    I doubt MID’s actions are an isolated incident and serve to further illustrate how disfunctional irrigation districts can become.
    Perhaps a thorough independent audit would be in order ?

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

The Facts of Life - The Bulwark
The Facts of Life – The Bulwark
My suggestion last week that perhaps the best way some of us who’ve been conservatives can now help the country is to help the Biden administration succeed, and help the Democratic party move to the center, seems to have stirred up a minor tempest in the conservative teapot. I asked whether one shouldn’t consider allying…
thebulwark.com
WSJ News Exclusive | Texas Electric Bills Were $28 Billion Higher Under Deregulation
WSJ News Exclusive | Texas Electric Bills Were $28 Billion Higher Under Deregulation
Texas’s deregulated electricity market left millions in the dark last week. For the past 20 years, its consumers have paid more for their electricity than state residents who are served by traditional utilities, a WSJ investigation found.
www.wsj.com
The making of Madison Cawthorn: How falsehoods helped propel the career of a new pro-Trump star of the far right
The making of Madison Cawthorn: How falsehoods helped propel the career of a new pro-Trump star of the far right
Cawthorn has emerged as one of the most visible figures among newly arrived House Republicans, who have promoted baseless assertions and pushed a radicalized ideology that has become a driving force in the GOP.
www.washingtonpost.com
Los Angeles Just Opened a Tiny Home Village for the Homeless
Los Angeles Just Opened a Tiny Home Village for the Homeless
The colorful community was built in just 13 weeks!
www.housebeautiful.com
California's coronavirus strain looks increasingly dangerous: 'The devil is already here'
California’s coronavirus strain looks increasingly dangerous: ‘The devil is already here’
California’s coronavirus strain is more transmissible than its predecessors, is more resistant to vaccines and may cause more severe cases of COVID-19.
www.latimes.com
More Than 150 Biz Leaders Endorse Biden's Sweeping COVID Package
More Than 150 Biz Leaders Endorse Biden’s Sweeping COVID Package
More than 150 business leaders from various industries have signed a letter backing President Joe Biden’s $1.9 trillion COVID-19 relief…
talkingpointsmemo.com
Exclusive: Defeated and impeached, Trump still commands the loyalty of the GOP's voters
Exclusive: Defeated and impeached, Trump still commands the loyalty of the GOP’s voters
www.usatoday.com
The Christian Prophets Who Say Trump Is Coming Again
The Christian Prophets Who Say Trump Is Coming Again
In the growing community of charismatic Christian prophecy, faith in Donald Trump’s imminent return to the White House is a new dividing line.
www.politico.com
AOC raises $1 million in Texas relief, heading to Houston as Ted Cruz douses Cancun flames
AOC raises $1 million in Texas relief, heading to Houston as Ted Cruz douses Cancun flames
The New York congresswoman said she would travel to Houston to highlight the problems faced by Texans hit by power outages and freezing weather.
www.newsweek.com
Rush Limbaugh Did His Best to Ruin America
Rush Limbaugh Did His Best to Ruin America
How the right-wing talk radio icon corrupted the Republican Party, spread hate, racism, and lies, and laid the groundwork for Trumpism
www.rollingstone.com
?I Don?t Trust the People Above Me?: Riot Squad Cops Open Up About Disastrous Response to Capitol Insurrection
“I Don’t Trust the People Above Me”: Riot Squad Cops Open Up About Disastrous Response to Capitol Insurrection
Interviews with 19 current and former officers show how failures of leadership and communication put hundreds of Capitol cops at risk and allowed rioters to get dangerously close to members of Congress.
www.propublica.org
Opinion | Trump’s Non-Vindication
Opinion | Trump’s Non-Vindication
He may run again, but he won’t win another national election.
www.wsj.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design