• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Pursuing truth toward justice

The Valley Citizen

Pursuing truth toward justice
  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About

Low Rent Projects Don’t Pencil Out

July 26, 2014 By Bruce Frohman 1 Comment

At 17th and G
At 17th and G

News Item:  According to the July 14th edition of the Modesto Bee, Modesto’s newest public housing project will cost about $274,000 per unit to build. The Tower Project will be built at 17th and G Streets in the old water tower park. Will the project deliver good value for taxpayers?

Basic Apartment Finance

In the private sector, apartment buildings are constructed with an expected rate of return on capital of about eight percent or more. A return of five percent might be acceptable if the investor expects rents to rise. If rents rise, the rate of return increases over time, so the investor may be willing to accept a lower rate of return in the short run.

If the rate of return is inadequate, the apartments won’t be built. At $274,000 per unit, a private investor would not build it even if he could get fair market rent! Since taxpayers are footing the bill, no one in elected office seems to be concerned about whether the project pencils out. No one is looking to see whether the cost per unit represents a good value.

In Modesto, $274,000 today would buy a 4 bedroom home of over 2000 square feet. The apartments to be constructed will not be anywhere as large and would not be a comparable value. The Housing Authority would deliver a better product to the community if it purchased existing vacant single family homes and rented them out. Modesto presently has a large supply of vacant homes owing to depressed real estate values. If the law does not allow the Housing Authority to purchase single family homes, should the law be changed?

Simple Math

Simple calculations can determine how far out of whack the public housing project’s expenditures will be. At $274,000 per unit, with an 8 percent rate of return, net rental income on each unit would have to be $21,920 per year or $1826 per month AFTER expenses. If one figures that monthly expenses for property management, maintenance, and depreciation represent a minimum of twenty percent of rental income, the gross monthly rent on each unit would need to be $2191 in order to pencil out. Modesto does not have any apartment buildings that yield a rental income high enough to pencil out in this case.

If we do the same calculation with a rate of return of only 5 percent, the net rental income on each unit would need to be $13,700 per year or $1141 per month. Adding the twenty percent in operational costs, the gross monthly rental income of the project would need to be $1369. Modesto may have upscale apartment buildings that yield that amount of rental income. Many single family homes rent for less.

Why the Project Is Being Built

Low rent public housing projects are being built all over the United States and no one locally seems to care about the excessive cost per unit because the money is coming from the federal government. The Modesto City Council certainly doesn’t want to stop the project, even if it is a bad deal for the taxpayer.

During this writer’s service on the City Council from 1999-2003, he questioned the per unit cost of a low cost public housing project. He was told by a colleague to shut up because the project was being funded with federal money and if the council didn’t approve the project, the money would be lost to the community. Back in those days, the cost of construction per unit was much lower, but still seemed high. In recent years, costs per unit have risen faster than the rate of building construction and the value of existing real estate.

The City of Modesto is getting a project that will infuse a substantial sum of money into the local economy and provide some housing for its most economically challenged citizens. Taxpayers don’t seem to notice the high cost per unit and the programs have minimal oversight.

Defenders of the program state that the high cost per unit is the result of special government requirements, including union labor. However, this excuse does not justify the cost of the program.

The Never Ending Need for Public Housing

If one checks with the local Housing Authority, a long waiting list always exists for subsidized rents. The tragedy is that if every project built was cost effective, or if existing vacant properties were acquired, many more units could be put into service for the same amount of money. Many more people could be served with a better quality of life. Local property values would rise as public housing could soak up the surplus of existing single family homes. While we should all care, no one seems to.

 

 

Filed Under: Featured, History Tagged With: Affordable Housing Modesto, Tower Project Modesto

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Dick Hagerty says

    August 2, 2014 at 5:25 pm

    Bruce
    We have not always agreed on things
    but these comments are exceptionally accurate!
    But hey, its not our money right? It is Federal money and that comes from out of the air, or somewhere….
    Great comments

    dick

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

?Monster Fracks? Are Getting Far Bigger. And Far Thirstier.
“Monster Fracks” Are Getting Far Bigger. And Far Thirstier.
A Times analysis shows that increasingly complex oil and gas wells now require astonishing volumes of water to fracture the bedrock and release fossil fuels, threatening America’s fragile aquifers.
www.nytimes.com
Newsom urges SCOTUS to consider encampment ruling that has 'paralyzed' California cities
Newsom urges SCOTUS to consider encampment ruling that has ‘paralyzed’ California cities
The Democratic governor’s intervention lays down a mark in a legal dispute with potentially profound implications for one of California’s most pressing issues.
www.politico.com
Clarence Thomas Secretly Participated in Koch Network Donor Events
Clarence Thomas Secretly Participated in Koch Network Donor Events
Thomas has attended at least two Koch donor summits, putting him in the extraordinary position of having helped a political network that has brought multiple cases before the Supreme Court.
www.propublica.org
How hungry is California? Millions struggle to eat well in an abundant state
How hungry is California? Millions struggle to eat well in an abundant state
How bad is hunger in California? A lot depends on your access to food aid, which expanded during the COVID-19 pandemic but now is being reduced.
calmatters.org
Sacramento DA sues city over homeless encampments
Sacramento DA sues city over homeless encampments
Sacramento County had nearly 9,300 homeless people in 2022, based on data from the annual Point in Time count. That was up 67% from 2019. Roughly three-quarters of the county’s homeless population….
www.mercurynews.com
At Last, a Real Possibility to Avoid Catastrophic Climate Change
At Last, a Real Possibility to Avoid Catastrophic Climate Change
After decades of minimal action, Congress passed the largest and most comprehensive piece of climate legislation in U.S. history. Will we make the most of this opportunity?
www.audubon.org
How the fentanyl crisis' fourth wave has hit every corner of the US
How the fentanyl crisis’ fourth wave has hit every corner of the US
The epidemic’s staggering scale and infiltration of communities is laid bare in a new study.
www.bbc.com
Can licensed tent villages ease California's homelessness epidemic? This nonprofit thinks so
Can licensed tent villages ease California’s homelessness epidemic? This nonprofit thinks so
Taking people off the street and into tents is a new twist on homeless shelter being explored by the San Francisco-based Urban Alchemy in two tent villages operating in Los Angeles and Culver City.
www.latimes.com
Mississippi has problems, but it's handling homelessness better than L.A.
Mississippi has problems, but it’s handling homelessness better than L.A.
The public tends to blame homelessness on poverty, drug use, crime or even warm weather. But other cities don’t have L.A. levels of street homelessness because they have more available housing.
www.latimes.com
Neo-Nazis March Through Florida Park
Neo-Nazis March Through Florida Park
The demonstrators raised “Heil Hitler” salutes and waved flags with swastikas.
www.thedailybeast.com
Families have high hopes for Gavin Newsom's CARE Courts. Providers want to lower expectations
Families have high hopes for Gavin Newsom’s CARE Courts. Providers want to lower expectations
Gov. Gavin Newsom?s experiment to push Californians with mental illness off the streets and into treatment, CARE Court, starts soon.
calmatters.org
Pope says 'backward' U.S. conservatives have replaced faith with ideology
Pope says ‘backward’ U.S. conservatives have replaced faith with ideology
Pope Francis has blasted the “backwardness” of some conservatives in the U.S. Catholic Church. He says they have replaced faith with ideology and that a correct understanding of Catholic doctrine allows for change over time.
apnews.com

Find us on Facebook

pp
The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design