• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About
  • RSS Icon

Modesto Bee Column Establishes New Low in Water Debate

March 16, 2013 By Eric Caine Leave a Comment

Tuolumne River, drying up near Modesto
Tuolumne River, drying up near Modesto

In slightly fewer than six-hundred words that may have set a record for errors per word, last Thursday’s Community Column in the Modesto Bee established a new low in our region’s ongoing debate about water. Written by Turlock’s Mike Romeo, the column contains numerous factual errors and at least one major conceptual error.

The conceptual error stems from Romeo’s assumption that those who pay for a dam own the water in the dam. Water is a public resource. Its distribution depends on a political process involving public input.

But even if Romeo’s assumption about dams and ownership of water were true, his numbers are wildly wrong. Romeo claims the Turlock Irrigation District (TID) paid 68 percent of the cost of Don Pedro Dam. According to the Modesto Irrigation District’s, “The Greening of Paradise Valley,” the total cost of Don Pedro Dam was $115, 696,000. Of that total, the TID paid $32,071,000. That’s 27 percent, not 68 percent. The largest share of the cost of Don Pedro Dam was paid by the city of San Francisco, at $47,380,000. By Romeo’s logic, the majority share of the water should belong to San Francisco.

Romeo’s factual errors actually begin with his first sentence, where he says the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) proposes, “to increase flows from Lake Don Pedro into the Tuolumne River” by 188 percent. In fact, the SWRCB proposes to restore flows along the Tuolumne to 35 percent of the historical average. That’s a 15 percent increase over the current 20 percent. It’s anybody’s guess where Romeo got the “188 percent” figure.

Like other opponents of increased river flows, Romeo tries to frame his argument in terms of farmers versus fish. But increased river flows are important not only to fish but also to San Joaquin Delta farmers, who are facing ever-increasing problems due to rising salinity in the Delta. In fact, the entire Delta ecosystem is imperiled in large part because of water diversions from our biggest rivers. A major reason for increased flows is to reduce salinity in the Delta. Put simply, the SWRCB is asking local farmers and urban users to conserve 15% of current use for the well-being of fish and Delta farmers, not to mention the entire Delta ecosystem.

Romeo makes the proposal to increase flows seem like the product of random guesswork, writing that there is no evidence that increased flows will help salmon. But according to the Natural Resources Defense Council, conclusions about the need for increased flows were the result of research by, “Scientists and fishery managers with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, the State Water Resources Control Board, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the Bay Institute, as well as independent scientific peer reviews and other conservation and fishing groups.” In other words, scientific testimony overwhelmingly supports increased flows.

In addition to numerous factual errors, Romeo’s column contains some assertions that are downright bizarre. At one point he writes, “They [SWRCB] also cannot assure that released water will make it to the salmon at the Golden Gate.” Huh? Where has anyone suggested increased flows are intended for “salmon at the Golden Gate”?

Maybe partisan zeal got the best of Mike Romeo, and he didn’t bother to check his facts. But that doesn’t excuse the Modesto Bee. In choosing to publish Romeo’s errors and misstatements shortly before next week’s hearings on restoring the Delta, Bee editors have shown a callous disregard for their obligation to deliver accurate information to Valley citizens. Bee readers deserve better service from the only major newspaper in the region.

 

Filed Under: Environment, Featured Tagged With: Restoration of flows along Tuolumne River, State Water Resources Control Board Tuolumne River, Tuolumne River water diversions

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

Mike Pence Can?t Walk Away from the Big Lie - The Bulwark
Mike Pence Can’t Walk Away from the Big Lie – The Bulwark
Targeted on Jan. 6 for saying the election was valid, he now plays footsie with the conspiracy theorists. It’s in keeping with his character.
thebulwark.com
On Voting Rights, GOP Lawyers Say the Quiet Part Out Loud - The Bulwark
On Voting Rights, GOP Lawyers Say the Quiet Part Out Loud – The Bulwark
Arguing before the Supreme Court, they admit their case isn’t about principle or election integrity, it’s just about winning.
thebulwark.com
Could Biden Be the Most Transformative President in Living Memory? - LA Progressive
Could Biden Be the Most Transformative President in Living Memory? – LA Progressive
Most Transformative President – Biden has the chance to lead a green and digital recovery that would create millions of good jobs.
www.laprogressive.com
Louis DeJoy Is Killing It
Louis DeJoy Is Killing It
While Biden dithers, Trump’s minion wrecks the postal service.
nymag.com
So What if Romney Doesn?t Solve the ?Root Causes? of Poverty?
So What if Romney Doesn’t Solve the Root Causes of Poverty?
We handle problems all the time without dealing with their root causes.
nymag.com
The Facts of Life - The Bulwark
The Facts of Life – The Bulwark
My suggestion last week that perhaps the best way some of us who’ve been conservatives can now help the country is to help the Biden administration succeed, and help the Democratic party move to the center, seems to have stirred up a minor tempest in the conservative teapot. I asked whether one shouldn’t consider allying…
thebulwark.com
WSJ News Exclusive | Texas Electric Bills Were $28 Billion Higher Under Deregulation
WSJ News Exclusive | Texas Electric Bills Were $28 Billion Higher Under Deregulation
Texas’s deregulated electricity market left millions in the dark last week. For the past 20 years, its consumers have paid more for their electricity than state residents who are served by traditional utilities, a WSJ investigation found.
www.wsj.com
The making of Madison Cawthorn: How falsehoods helped propel the career of a new pro-Trump star of the far right
The making of Madison Cawthorn: How falsehoods helped propel the career of a new pro-Trump star of the far right
Cawthorn has emerged as one of the most visible figures among newly arrived House Republicans, who have promoted baseless assertions and pushed a radicalized ideology that has become a driving force in the GOP.
www.washingtonpost.com
Los Angeles Just Opened a Tiny Home Village for the Homeless
Los Angeles Just Opened a Tiny Home Village for the Homeless
The colorful community was built in just 13 weeks!
www.housebeautiful.com
California's coronavirus strain looks increasingly dangerous: 'The devil is already here'
California’s coronavirus strain looks increasingly dangerous: ‘The devil is already here’
California’s coronavirus strain is more transmissible than its predecessors, is more resistant to vaccines and may cause more severe cases of COVID-19.
www.latimes.com
More Than 150 Biz Leaders Endorse Biden's Sweeping COVID Package
More Than 150 Biz Leaders Endorse Biden’s Sweeping COVID Package
More than 150 business leaders from various industries have signed a letter backing President Joe Biden’s $1.9 trillion COVID-19 relief…
talkingpointsmemo.com
Exclusive: Defeated and impeached, Trump still commands the loyalty of the GOP's voters
Exclusive: Defeated and impeached, Trump still commands the loyalty of the GOP’s voters
www.usatoday.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design