• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About
  • RSS Icon

The Only Game In Town: Why Every Community Needs Newspapers

June 2, 2011 By Eric Caine 3 Comments

New Year’s Day, Eric Johnston and Mark Vasché published the Modesto Bee’s annual pledge to Bee readers. Johnston and Vasché pledged to, “adhere to the highest journalistic standards of accuracy, fairness, impartiality and independence,” and added the plea, “that readers—and we ourselves—be respectful of people of differing viewpoints.”

Johnston and Vasché’s words are best understood within the context of a remarkably candid speech made by Bee publisher James B. McClatchy at the Bee’s 25-year Club’s annual meeting in 2002 (the Bee and a host of other newspapers are owned by McClatchy Newspapers; James B. McClatchy died in 2006).

In response to the self-posed question, “Why do newspapers exist,” McClatchy said, “The main responses are, one, to make money and have influence in a community; and two, to serve the public.” Note that McClatchy conflated making money and having influence into one purpose. He then said, “Commercial success is the crucial companion to all this, making it possible for us to fulfill our responsibilities.”

While making money and having influence don’t necessarily conflict with serving the public, it’s not difficult to imagine cases when these interests collide. One such example is population growth. While a newspaper profits from growth, growth doesn’t necessarily serve the public; some studies have shown that growth, especially in the form of sprawl, actually places a burden on Central Valley residents in the form of increased costs for infrastructure and services that growth does not pay for. And a newspaper’s “commercial success” depends not only on the usual sources of advertising revenue—car dealers, department stores and specialty stores—but especially on real estate ads. Just take a look at the Sunday real estate section sometime and imagine the dollars it represents to the local paper.

Very often, the political and commercial interests of newspapers and news magazines are obvious and simply taken for granted. Conservatives routinely debunk any news from the New York Times, liberals refer to “Faux News,” and Rupert Murdoch’s ownership of media is rarely seen as a venture in the public interest except by supporters of Murdoch’s brand of politics.

And while it is a lesser known aspect of our early history, newspapers have almost always reflected political interests. Thomas Jefferson hired Phillip Freneau to publish a newspaper critical of George Washington, and Benjamin Franklin Bache’s American Aurora was famous for its scathing political commentary. It’s hard to imagine our Founding Fathers at one another’s throats, but Jefferson and Washington had bitter differences, as did Jefferson and Hamilton. Early on, those differences got expressed via newspapers with competing viewpoints that were proudly partisan. Jeff Pasley’s, The Tyranny of Printers, documents the history of these early newspapers in fascinating detail.

Absent newspapers with competing viewpoints, citizens receive news shaped by one set of pressures for profit and influence. And when one newspaper is the only game in town, it’s easy to forget John Stuart Mill’s observation that,

Truth, in the great practical concerns of life, is so much a question of the reconciling and combining of opposites that very few have minds sufficiently capacious and impartial to make the adjustment with an approach to correctness, and it has to be made by the rough process of a struggle between combatants fighting under hostile banners.

When there is one newspaper, there is one set of rules, one arbiter of “truth,” one judge of what is or is not “impartial” or “civil.” Thus, the Bee can sermonize on civility and print a letter comparing Carmen Sabatino to a “proverbial pile of dog poop.” It can suppress a column by a Community Columnist while defending freedom of speech. It can justify any number of self-serving policies because freedom and civility and impartiality are abstractions into which the Bee (or anyone or institution) can pour ad hoc meanings convenient to its purposes. And, as James McClatchy professed, making money and having influence are the default reasons for having a newspaper. Bottom line: Politics and the profit motive can have distorting effects on the news.

None of this means the Bee is wrong, or even misguided. It’s perfectly reasonable to pursue influence and profit. However, it does not serve the public to have one and only one arbiter of freedom, civility and impartiality. By definition, one entity is not impartial, especially when its owner justifies its very existence in terms of having influence and making money.

And that’s why every community needs newspapers.

Filed Under: Featured, History

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Catalina Aguillon says

    July 3, 2011 at 6:35 am

    Having a variety of newspapers is essential to developing a well balanced view of our community. However, I find it interesting that as media expands, lending itself to the spread of diverse views, we have become more polarized choosing to consume only that which adheres to our own views. Sadly, it appears as though even when choices are provided, this does little to stimulate objectivity.

    Reply
  2. hotshot bald cop says

    August 30, 2011 at 8:10 am

    I never thought of it that way, well put!

    Reply
  3. green hosting reseller says

    September 29, 2011 at 12:43 pm

    I like this site very much, Its a real nice situation to read and receive info . cpanel reseller | whm reseller |

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

Californians: Here's why your housing costs are so high
Californians: Here’s why your housing costs are so high
Half the state’s households struggle to afford the roof over their heads. Here’s what you need to know about one of California’s most vexing issues.
calmatters.org
Las Vegas Pushes to Become First City to Ban Ornamental Grass
Las Vegas Pushes to Become First City to Ban Ornamental Grass
A desert city built on a reputation for excess and indulgence wants to become a model for restraint and conservation with a first-in-the-nation policy banning grass that nobody walks on. Las Vegas-area water officials have spent two decades trying to get people to replace thirsty greenery with desert plants, and now they’re asking the Nevada Legislature to outlaw roughly 40% of the turf that’s left. The Southern Nevada Water Authority estimates there are almost 8 square miles (21 square kilometers) of “nonfunctional turf” in the metro area, grass that no one ever walks on or otherwise uses in
www.voanews.com
Half of Republicans believe false accounts of deadly U.S. Capitol riot-Reuters/Ipsos poll
Half of Republicans believe false accounts of deadly U.S. Capitol riot-Reuters/Ipsos poll
Since the deadly Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol, former President Donald Trump and his Republican allies have pushed false and misleading accounts to downplay the event that left five dead and scores of others wounded. His supporters appear to have listened.
www.reuters.com
Inside the Koch-Backed Effort to Block the Largest Election-Reform Bill in Half a Century
Inside the Koch-Backed Effort to Block the Largest Election-Reform Bill in Half a Century
On a leaked conference call, leaders of dark-money groups and an aide to Mitch McConnell expressed frustration with the popularity of the legislation, even among Republican voters.
www.newyorker.com
New Zealand raises minimum wage to $20 an hour
New Zealand raises minimum wage to $20 an hour
Taxes on the richest New Zealanders are being raised
www.independent.co.uk
The Invisible Asylum | City Journal
The Invisible Asylum | City Journal
Olympia, Washington, is a microcosm of the problems created by the emptying of mental hospitals.
www.city-journal.org
California needs affordable housing. Could these bills help? | CalMatters
California needs affordable housing. Could these bills help? | CalMatters
Key legislators push duplexes, looser regulations and more money to boost housing supply.
calmatters.org
The rich-poor gap in America is obscene. So let's fix it – here's how | Bernie Sanders
The rich-poor gap in America is obscene. So let’s fix it – here’s how | Bernie Sanders
While working people toil, the richest have never have it so good. It’s time to fight back – our democracy depends on it
www.theguardian.com
Sen. Bernie Sanders' Next Progressive Frontier: Reshaping A 'Rigged' Tax System
Sen. Bernie Sanders’ Next Progressive Frontier: Reshaping A ‘Rigged’ Tax System
Sanders will introduce legislation Thursday to restore the corporate tax rate to 35% and add a new progressive tax on the estates of the wealthiest Americans.
www.npr.org
Perspective | Five myths about poverty
Perspective | Five myths about poverty
No, it’s not just an inner city problem. And it’s not the result of individual failure.
www.washingtonpost.com
Los Angeles police clash with protesters in fight to evict major homeless encampment
Los Angeles police clash with protesters in fight to evict major homeless encampment
Echo Park Lake site has become a battleground in the city’s worsening housing and homelessness crisis during the pandemic
www.theguardian.com
The High Stakes in the Amazon Union Fight in Alabama - The Bulwark
The High Stakes in the Amazon Union Fight in Alabama – The Bulwark
It’s about workplace democracy, and could affect not just the tech giant’s employees but those of other firms.
thebulwark.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design