Home More Stories Time to End Janice Keating’s Fake Grievance Tour at MID

Time to End Janice Keating’s Fake Grievance Tour at MID

14
Time to End Janice Keating’s Fake Grievance Tour at MID
Mke Moradian, walking and working for MID farmers and ratepayers, September, 2026

There’s nothing radical about Mike Moradian’s platform as he campaigns against Janice Keating for a seat on the Modesto Irrigation District’s (MID) Board of Directors. He’s a common sense candidate who has built two successful local businesses and wants to bring stability and fundamental accounting practices to MID.

“Janice Keating ran on promises to control expenses,” said Moradian last week, “instead, she’s become a cost.”

Moradian was doubtless referring to costs incurred from Keating’s specious lawsuit against MID and Director Robert Frobose and an abuse of staff case that required an outside investigator to review and document. More recently, MID spent even more money on yet another of Keating’s fake grievances.

The lawsuit Keating filed in 2024 was so egregiously baseless that the judge ordered her to pay almost $45,000 in legal and court fees. The abuse of staff case occurred at a restaurant in Los Angeles when MID Directors and select staff members were on official business.

The abuse of staff case was especially disturbing because it confirmed allegations of workplace violence. According to a report in the Modesto Bee, Keating’s abuse of staff started as early as 2023 and included loud cursing and throwing a clipboard at an MID employee at the Los Angeles restaurant venue.

Keating’s most recent attempt to wound the District and smear Director Frobose forced another investigation after she claimed Frobose, “deliberately bumped into Director Larry Byrd which caused Byrd to bump into Director Janice Keating’s chair and knocked Keating into the dais.”

Here’s a condensed version of the report by the private investigator MID hired to look into Keating’s claims:

Mike Moradian Modesto CA September 2026
Mke Moradian, walking and working for MID farmers and ratepayers, September, 2026

“Multiple third-party witness accounts….were corroborated by available video footage….Keating’s own account….suffered from internal inconsistencies and from clear conflicts with the video footage…The third-party witness accounts and related video evidence contradict Keating’s account of events and support the ‘not sustained’ finding.”

Keating had reported she had left this year’s April 14 Board Meeting, “crying, and immediately drove away without speaking to anyone.” Video footage showed she left the board meeting with Larry Byrd and chatted with him for several minutes afterwards in the MID parking lot.

Perhaps not coincidentally, Keating voted with Byrd last December 16 to discontinue an investigation into Byrd’s alleged misappropriation of MID surface water on the AB La Grange Ranch after preliminary research confirmed he had used that water on out-of-district almond trees. Byrd’s vote in his own interest is being investigated by the Fair Political Practices Commission.

Since then, Keating has received campaign contributions from Larry Byrd’s cattle company ($1,000), Byrd’s partner and brother Tim Byrd ($950), the AB La Grange Ranch — where Ty Angle is a partner with the Byrd brothers — ($1,000), Ty Angle’s son Brandon Angle ($3,000), and Cal Coast Almonds — principals Ty Angle’s son Chris and Angle himself — ($5,000).

Mike Moradian has built two successful local businesses, one in construction estimation and another in pest control. He will join Directors Chris Ott and Robert Frobose in a majority vote to bring transparency and fundamental accounting principles to an irrigation district crippled by conflicts of interest, bogus grievances, and inadequate audits.

The civic heart of America has always been sustained by its shopkeepers, service providers, contractors, craftspeople, farmers, and laborers. Mike Moradian has stepped up to answer MID’s urgent call for public service. MID farmers and ratepayers need him now.

14 COMMENTS

  1. There is even a better choice for MID board division 2 and that is me, John Van Oostende! I worked for MID for 30 years and I am backed by the MID workers that know I am the best person for the position! There is no learning curve with me and I bring common sense and civility to the board. We don’t need an outsider or more problems in our board. Vote John van Oostende for board!!

    • Mr. Oostende: Like Larry Byrd, you seem to think MID is a closed fiefdom, existing only for “insiders” like Mr. Byrd and his cronies. MID in-district farmers and ratepayers are the literal owners and “bosses” of a public utility that provides some of the best service and pricing in the state. We all appreciate MID’s employees. However, Director Byrd’s term has not been in any way a recommendation for “insider” occupancy of the board despite his many years as an MID employee. Instead, he’s been shown to be a liar and almost certainly, according to the 4Creeks’ investigation, applied MID surface water out of district. He’s also reported and been billed for 2 acre-feet of water on properties that need at least 3.5 acre-feet. None of these examples would lead anyone to believe that long-term service as an employee necessarily amounts to a guarantee of good service as a director. In fact, quite the opposite! In short, “outsiders” like Robert Frobose, Chris Ott and Mike Moradian are the legal guardians and responsible managers of the district. MID ratepayers and in-district farmers democratically choose their representatives to serve them. It’s called public service. They are the true insiders here. Some of you seem to have forgotten that MID is a PUBLIC utility dedicated to PUBLIC service, not an insider clique or private fiefdom for cronies and friends.

    • My problem with your candidacy is that your argument is the same argument Larry Byrd first made when he ran for MID Director. “Vote for me because I have 30 years of experience as an MID employee, and the employees support me.” A voter has to wonder where your loyalty lays, with the ratepayers or with your buddies that you worked with? You know full well there have been mistakes made and abuses, but are you willing to hold your former coworkers accountable? Will you curry favor with those you were closest to or be unbiased and independent? The current Board is contentious precisely because someone like your profile ascended to the Director’s position. The Byrd fiasco should have been handled in-house, investigated and audited in a month or less, but management couldn’t handle their business because of personal relationship. I don’t know you, but I know what the current problem is, and you track with more of the same.

    • Oostende you have publicly acknowledged that you would rather just get along than put a stop to Larry Byrd stealing from the ratepayers. Directors have a responsibility to protect ratepayers even if it is uncomfortable. You have the insider mentality of lets move along nothing to see here.

  2. Mr. Caine, if I recall correctly, the abusive outburst in Los Angeles was prompted by Janice wanting her adult child’s dinner put on the MID card. Or, maybe she argued that she would expense his meal and seek reimbursement. When Dana said the District would not/could not pay for a non-employee, Keating verbally abused Dana and threw the clipboard at her. Witnesses said Keating had been drinking. Not drunk, but unruly.

  3. I don’t like Moravian—and the “successful business “ trope is unconvincing.

    However, I will always vote against Keating. She’s a crook and a drunk. I consider myself one of the nine people who prevented her political rise to supervisor.

  4. Janice Keating is an embarrassment to intelligent hard-working women. And let’s not forget that the Board requested Janice Keating to apologize to the MID employee, Dana, and she has refused to give an apology.

    • Unbelievable! Dana is a very good person, longtime ethical public employee just doing the right thing according to MID rules. Several witnesses. Keating does not have any class.

  5. Thank you Mr. Van Oostende for showing us that you’re not fit for public office. What you don’t say reveals as much as what you do say.

    You wrote, “I bring common sense and civility to the board.” You’re not on the board, so you in fact don’t bring anything to it. But it’s clear you feel entitled to be on the board because you’re in insider in the same way Larry Byrd feels entitled to steal water and lie about it.

    You could have said that, if elected, you will bring accountability and transparency to the board, but you used the words “common sense and civility”. It seems the common sense and civility you and your ilk want is an agreement among cronies to have each other’s backs at the expense of transparency, accountability, and MID rate payers’ best interests. We rate payers have had enough of that kind of “common sense and civility”, which is why Mike Moradian’s campaign has gained traction and why Robert Frobose is admired for his loyalty to rate payers and to the principles of good governance.

    You close your bit of self-promotion with this claim: “We don’t need an outsider or more problems in our board.” Who is “we” in that sentence? It’s clear that you and people like Larry Byrd and Janice Keating view MID and seats on the board as private property to be used for private gain, even though MID is in fact a public utility. It is not your board. It is the rate payers’ board, even though Larry Byrd treats it like private property and even though you apparently think it belongs to insiders like yourself.

    I encourage you to campaign door to door with your message of standing up for insiders’ interests over the rights of MID rate payers. It will bring more clarity to this campaign. Thank you for your unintentional service.

    • We’re sorry you’re sad, George. But neither your feelings nor URLs constitute an argument, let alone a convincing one. Next time you step up to the plate, bring a bat.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here