• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About
  • RSS Icon

Vance Kennedy: Bee Editors All Wet on Water

June 21, 2016 By Vance Kennedy 4 Comments

Dr. Vance Kennedy
Dr. Vance Kennedy

Dr. Vance Kennedy has long been concerned that too many people ignore the long-term hazards of drip irrigation, especially in terms of increased soil salinity and reduced groundwater recharge. A recent Modesto Bee editorial criticizing water subsidies for farmers provoked the following reaction from Dr. Kennedy, an award-winning hydrologist who is retired from the U.S. Geological Survey:

I am a 93 year old retired research hydrologist who is concerned about the future of this region. I believe we have an obligation to plan ahead for future generations, and this is my effort to have community leaders look ahead. I anticipate sending this note to a range of local leaders in the hope the views presented here will be given some consideration, especially when compared to those espoused by the Modesto Bee in a recent editorial. I welcome comments.

In a June 10 editorial, The Modesto Bee argued emphatically that the Modesto Irrigation District’s practice of subsidizing water for agriculture should be abandoned and added that the, “MID must make electricity customers a top priority.” I strongly disagree, if they mean to greatly increase flood irrigation rates and remove entirely the so-called “subsidy.” What has not been recognized is that there has long been a two-way subsidy between Modesto residents and nearby farmers. The farmers recharge the water supply under the city of Modesto at no charge to the city, and, in exchange, electric rate payers  help cover irrigation costs.

The value of a long term reliable water supply and maintenance of agriculture and related jobs far exceeds the importance of electricity rates. Without water and agriculture, this area would be an economic disaster. Bee editors are concerned about the poor having to pay high electric bills, but at least poor people have jobs with some income. If we lose farm income, we will lose jobs and income throughout the region.

If all farmers go to drip irrigation because of high flood irrigation rates, the water table can be expected to decline rapidly, resulting in greatly increased pumping costs and ultimately placing us in the same dire circumstances as the Westlands Water District, where subsidence, depleted groundwater supplies, and soil salinity have driven surface water prices upward beyond sustainability. Rumor has it that the irrigation charge here could go more than twenty times beyond the present rate. The impact on the economy is impossible to predict, but it could be major.

The Bee overwhelmingly emphasizes the electricity rates and gives essentially no recognition to the benefits of past and present low irrigation rates, which encouraged farmers to keep flood irrigating so that the water table recharged. I have spoken to a Bee editor friend and have simply agreed to disagree. Since I have been unable to get the Bee to recognize my arguments and give them serious consideration, I have decided to present my views elsewhere.

It is true that irrigation rates have been very low in the past and apparently have been “subsidized.” In return, agriculture has assured a reliable groundwater supply superior to most other areas in the Valley and provided huge economic support to Valley communities. Last year, Stanislaus County farm products were valued in excess of four billion dollars. A common assumption, known as the “multiplier,” is that those dollars cause three times their value in local economic activities or perhaps twelve billion dollars in one year.

If we assume that MID farmers account for only a quarter of the county’s agricultural income, the value is about three billion dollars. Contrast that figure with the hundred million dollars over perhaps ten years of claimed “subsidy” by the Bee, or perhaps ten million dollars per year. The ratio of economic benefit to cost for the community is about three-hundred thousand to one. Where else can you get that sort of return year after year?  If a new industry producing three billion dollars per year were considering coming to town, what sort of “subsidy” would be offered? I am sure it would be a lot. The Bee would not be fighting it, and the Chamber of Commerce would rave about it.

Farmers are already going to drip irrigation on a large scale and increased irrigation rates will simply encourage much more of that practice. It does reduce water use and is very convenient. The short-term benefits are obvious, and the long-term harm is ignored. Any good politician knows to push for short-term benefits, just as any newspaper does.

The long-term harm includes greatly reduced groundwater recharge and a buildup of salinity in soils. The State has finally recognized, to a limited degree, the value of groundwater in a warming, and perhaps drier, climate. Because there is a lot of inertia in natural systems, depletion of groundwater will occur gradually in our area. Such depletion has already occurred elsewhere in the Valley and the consequences were soil salinity and subsidence wherever there are clays in the geologic profile. Those consequences can be avoided here if we just encourage farmers to continue flood irrigation, the opposite of what the Bee’s efforts recommend. The general public is not concerned until depleted groundwater becomes a major problem. By that time, the danger will be virtually irreversible. Meanwhile, the Bee addresses only immediate problems and fails to look long term.

What will we do years from now, when we have depleted our supply of good groundwater? It is the old case of unintended consequences.

I have long been interested in learning how to measure the percentage of flood irrigation water recharging the water table. To my knowledge, there is at present no accurate method of doing this. I believe that many past studies have relied on estimating evaporation of the flood irrigation waters and transpiration by plants. Knowing the volume of water applied and estimating those two factors, with accompanying errors, the remaining amount is considered groundwater recharge.

There have been efforts in the past to do a better job of estimating groundwater recharge, but none locally, to my knowledge. It would be extremely beneficial to everyone if an accurate measure of such recharge were available. With an accurate measure of groundwater supply to cities, I believe a case could be made for paying farmers for groundwater recharge. Perhaps such an accurate measure would encourage us to reevaluate and revise our understanding of the agricultural “subsidy.” In that light, we might even be more than happy to continue encouraging farmers to maintain sound and sustainable flood irrigation practices.

Filed Under: Environment, Featured

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Damon woods says

    June 21, 2016 at 12:05 pm

    Great article- get this out to the MID customers

    Reply
  2. Tom Orvis says

    June 29, 2016 at 3:46 am

    Thank you Vance. We don’t always agree but this is well said, sensible and defensible!

    Reply
  3. Dan Langhoff says

    June 29, 2016 at 7:15 pm

    Very interesting and valuable perspective. Once again we see how nuanced serious issues really are. We’ve known for some time about the serious draw-down of Valley aquifers (e.g., the history of city wells). Some real data on recharge rates would really benefit the discussion–but perhaps seriously depress us all.

    Reply
  4. unfairly dismissed says

    July 28, 2020 at 2:49 pm

    I cannot thank you enough for the blog article.Really thank you! Great.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

So What if Romney Doesn?t Solve the ?Root Causes? of Poverty?
So What if Romney Doesn’t Solve the Root Causes of Poverty?
We handle problems all the time without dealing with their root causes.
nymag.com
The Facts of Life - The Bulwark
The Facts of Life – The Bulwark
My suggestion last week that perhaps the best way some of us who’ve been conservatives can now help the country is to help the Biden administration succeed, and help the Democratic party move to the center, seems to have stirred up a minor tempest in the conservative teapot. I asked whether one shouldn’t consider allying…
thebulwark.com
WSJ News Exclusive | Texas Electric Bills Were $28 Billion Higher Under Deregulation
WSJ News Exclusive | Texas Electric Bills Were $28 Billion Higher Under Deregulation
Texas’s deregulated electricity market left millions in the dark last week. For the past 20 years, its consumers have paid more for their electricity than state residents who are served by traditional utilities, a WSJ investigation found.
www.wsj.com
The making of Madison Cawthorn: How falsehoods helped propel the career of a new pro-Trump star of the far right
The making of Madison Cawthorn: How falsehoods helped propel the career of a new pro-Trump star of the far right
Cawthorn has emerged as one of the most visible figures among newly arrived House Republicans, who have promoted baseless assertions and pushed a radicalized ideology that has become a driving force in the GOP.
www.washingtonpost.com
Los Angeles Just Opened a Tiny Home Village for the Homeless
Los Angeles Just Opened a Tiny Home Village for the Homeless
The colorful community was built in just 13 weeks!
www.housebeautiful.com
California's coronavirus strain looks increasingly dangerous: 'The devil is already here'
California’s coronavirus strain looks increasingly dangerous: ‘The devil is already here’
California’s coronavirus strain is more transmissible than its predecessors, is more resistant to vaccines and may cause more severe cases of COVID-19.
www.latimes.com
More Than 150 Biz Leaders Endorse Biden's Sweeping COVID Package
More Than 150 Biz Leaders Endorse Biden’s Sweeping COVID Package
More than 150 business leaders from various industries have signed a letter backing President Joe Biden’s $1.9 trillion COVID-19 relief…
talkingpointsmemo.com
Exclusive: Defeated and impeached, Trump still commands the loyalty of the GOP's voters
Exclusive: Defeated and impeached, Trump still commands the loyalty of the GOP’s voters
www.usatoday.com
The Christian Prophets Who Say Trump Is Coming Again
The Christian Prophets Who Say Trump Is Coming Again
In the growing community of charismatic Christian prophecy, faith in Donald Trump’s imminent return to the White House is a new dividing line.
www.politico.com
AOC raises $1 million in Texas relief, heading to Houston as Ted Cruz douses Cancun flames
AOC raises $1 million in Texas relief, heading to Houston as Ted Cruz douses Cancun flames
The New York congresswoman said she would travel to Houston to highlight the problems faced by Texans hit by power outages and freezing weather.
www.newsweek.com
Rush Limbaugh Did His Best to Ruin America
Rush Limbaugh Did His Best to Ruin America
How the right-wing talk radio icon corrupted the Republican Party, spread hate, racism, and lies, and laid the groundwork for Trumpism
www.rollingstone.com
?I Don?t Trust the People Above Me?: Riot Squad Cops Open Up About Disastrous Response to Capitol Insurrection
“I Don’t Trust the People Above Me”: Riot Squad Cops Open Up About Disastrous Response to Capitol Insurrection
Interviews with 19 current and former officers show how failures of leadership and communication put hundreds of Capitol cops at risk and allowed rioters to get dangerously close to members of Congress.
www.propublica.org

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design