• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Valley Citizen

Nature, Environment, History & Politics

The Valley Citizen

  • Arts
  • Education
  • Environment
  • History
  • Nature
  • Politics
  • Wit
  • About
  • RSS Icon

Water: When Markets Fail

May 27, 2016 By Eric Caine 2 Comments

Dollar a drop?
Dollar a drop?

Last week, Stanislaus Superior Court Judge William Mayhew ruled that the Oakdale Irrigation District’s (OID) On Farm Conservation Program couldn’t proceed until it addressed environmental concerns raised by Oakdale farmers Louis Brichetto and Robert Frobose. The ruling was yet another in a series of legal setbacks for a district determined to balance its budget with out-of-region water sales, and costs be damned.

The district’s ongoing legal woes are just another symptom of California’s misguided faith in markets as the controlling authorities for water policy. In theory, water sales represent win-win situations for all parties involved. In fact, they’ve become an exclusive system, benefitting a few market players at the expense of the general public.

Want examples? Consider the Westlands Water District, one of OID’s favored customers. Located in the arid western portion of the San Joaquin Valley, Westlands has poor groundwater and historically junior water rights. Nonetheless, it’s bought its way to enough political power to command tremendous water subsidies even while the state as whole has suffered the worst drought in public memory.

Last September, the federal government forgave a Westlands’ debt of $350 million dollars owed for its share of the Central Valley Project’s construction costs, guaranteed the district almost 900,000 acre feet of cheap federal water, and relaxed environmental standards for Westlands’ historic drainage problems.

But mostly because Westlands’ farmers have planted acre upon acre of permanent nut crops, even the guarantee of 900,000 acre feet of cheap water isn’t enough to slake the district’s enormous thirst. That’s why Westlands has been one of OID’s most reliable customers.

But recently, OID farmers and the public in general have become skeptical about OID’s claims to have “surplus water.” OID had to cancel a water sale last year when farmer Louis Brichetto pointed out the district hadn’t observed requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act, and OID’s latest water sale proposal is on legal hold, per Judge Mayhew.

Despite years of falling groundwater levels, requests from local farmers to be annexed into the district, the ongoing demise of the San Joaquin Delta and its devastating effects on Delta farmers, fisheries, and recreational users, OID insists that its water sales have no environmental impacts.

But no one should blame OID for its ongoing charade about “surplus water” and positive impacts. State and federal governments have long supported water sales on the theory that market-based decisions are far more effective than government standards.

One major effect has been to divert water from ecosystems necessary for farmers and fisheries with less political clout than behemoths like Westlands and Southern California’s Metropolitan Water District. The ongoing deterioration of the San Joaquin Delta damages the public interest in too many ways to list, but that doesn’t prevent us from continuing to divert Delta water to unsustainable farming operations to the south.

The San Joaquin Valley has become a vast monoculture, as nut trees replace staple food crops, driving prices up not only for foods people eat every day but for the water needed to grow them. Water that could be far more efficiently applied nearer its points of origin is sent to regions far less efficient at using it, resulting in losses from evaporation, costs of transfer, litigation, and reduced groundwater recharge.

In theory, markets should improve efficiencies and reduce costs. In fact, water sales have become a “costs-added” way of exploiting a public resource, with the public bearing the costs and fewer and fewer players reaping enormous benefits. In today’s water market, far too many people are getting soaked while far too few prosper at their expense.

 

Filed Under: Environment, Featured

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. River Dweller says

    May 28, 2016 at 5:19 am

    Well put Eric!
    Anyone in disagreement need only look at New Melones that has sat at what they say is 26% of historical capavity since before they started letting water go down the Stanislaus River per “government requirement”.
    3 out of 12 lakes are not at capacity, New Melones is one. http://cdec.water.ca.gov/cdecapp/resapp/getResGraphsMain.action
    Do they really think we are stupid enough to belive they aren’t getting a dime from all that water??
    When my well starts straining again this summer because it can’t pull water up for my home, who’s big money will pay for a new well?

    Reply
    • River Dweller says

      May 29, 2016 at 5:05 am

      I stand corrected, 41% of historical capacity and 26% of capacity.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Some comments may be held for moderation.

Primary Sidebar

Off The Wire

A South Texan?s Wild, Life-affirming Quest to Break a National Birding Record
A South Texan’s Wild, Life-affirming Quest to Break a National Birding Record
When she began her year-long bird-spotting adventure, Tiffany Kersten was lost and lonely. She ended up achieving a major milestone and finding her way.
www.texasmonthly.com
Ron Johnson tried to hand fake elector info to Mike Pence on Jan. 6, panel reveals
Ron Johnson tried to hand fake elector info to Mike Pence on Jan. 6, panel reveals
A top aide said the Wisconsin Republican senator wanted to give Pence the list of pro-Trump electors as he prepared to certify the 2020 election.
www.politico.com
Raffensperger says he wishes Fox News carried every Jan. 6 hearing
Raffensperger says he wishes Fox News carried every Jan. 6 hearing
“I think it would have helped our party heal, given [people] more facts.”
www.axios.com
'Not safe anymore': Portland confronts the limits of its support for homeless services
‘Not safe anymore’: Portland confronts the limits of its support for homeless services
Homeless encampments now spill well beyond Portland’s downtown core, dividing a city that has invested liberally in support services.
www.latimes.com
Republicans Will Do It Again
Republicans Will Do It Again
They have not been chastened by the revelations of the January 6 committee.
nymag.com
Birdman
Birdman
Bird Brother: A Falconer’s Journey and the Healing Power of Wildlife
www.earthisland.org
The Potato Roll Empire Bankrolling Christian Nationalist Doug Mastriano
The Potato Roll Empire Bankrolling Christian Nationalist Doug Mastriano
The Martins were bit players in politics, until they put Doug Mastriano one step away from becoming Pennsylvania’s next governor.
nymag.com
Roger Stone and Michael Flynn under fire over rallies ‘distorting Christianity’
Roger Stone and Michael Flynn under fire over rallies ‘distorting Christianity’
Prominent Christian leaders accuse Trump allies of spreading misinformation about election and Covid, while distorting Christian teachings at ReAwaken America events
www.theguardian.com
Major water cutbacks loom as shrinking Colorado River nears 'moment of reckoning'
Major water cutbacks loom as shrinking Colorado River nears ‘moment of reckoning’
As the Colorado River water shortage worsens, major cutbacks are needed to reduce most perilous risks, a federal official tells senators.
www.latimes.com
Trump Scammed Supporters Out of $250 Million for Nonexistent Fraud Fund
Trump Scammed Supporters Out of $250 Million for Nonexistent Fraud Fund
Supporters who thought they were donating to “election integrity” instead saw some of their money funneled to Trump hotels
www.rollingstone.com
Police Arrested 31 White Supremacists Crammed Into a U-Haul With a Detailed Riot Plan
Police Arrested 31 White Supremacists Crammed Into a U-Haul With a Detailed Riot Plan
Members of the Patriot Front were allegedly planning to disrupt a pride parade in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho.
www.vice.com
Dishonor, Trump’s and His Party’s, Is the Real January 6th Takeaway
Dishonor, Trump’s and His Party’s, Is the Real January 6th Takeaway
Liz Cheney, defying the G.O.P., offered a searing indictment of the former President at Thursday’s hearing.
www.newyorker.com
Trumpworld Lied To Your Face About The Election
Trumpworld Lied To Your Face About The Election
In the fall and winter of 2020, former President Trump’s top lieutenants…
talkingpointsmemo.com

Find us on Facebook

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Footer

The Valley Citizen
PO Box 156
Downtown Bear Postal
1509 K Street
Modesto, CA 95354

Email us at:
thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Subscribe for Free

* indicates required

Search

• Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2022 The Valley Citizen

Dedicated to the memory of John Michael Flint. Contact us at thevalleycitizen@sbcglobal.net

Editor and publisher: Eric Caine

Website customization and maintenance by Susan Henley Design