Home Politics Time for a Public Accounting of Water and Power Use on the Director’s Ranches

Time for a Public Accounting of Water and Power Use on the Director’s Ranches

0
Time for a Public Accounting of Water and Power Use on the Director’s Ranches
Iron frame by Todd Sill

Mike Moradian’s win in the Modesto Irrigation District (MID) campaign for a seat on the Board of Directors almost certainly guarantees there will be further investigation into Director Larry Byrd’s irrigation methods on the AB La Grange Ranch in southeastern Stanislaus County. Moradian prevailed in the three-person race. Incumbent Janice Keating, who had joined Byrd in opposing further inquiry, finished last.

Along with incumbent Director Robert Frobose, who won over 60% of the votes in his own race, Moradian favors transparency in government. So does incumbent Director Chris Ott, who was not up for election.

Last year’s 4Creeks investigation into Byrd’s alleged misappropriation of MID surface water raised more questions than it answered. Qualified readers of the report tend to agree it was truncated. It was missing a conclusion — almost as if by design. Investigators also failed to pursue accounting anomalies in Byrd’s pumping, power, and billing records.

Though 4Creeks claimed the study was “inconclusive,” investigators concluded that Byrd could not have used groundwater on his out-of-district orchards. There was only one other source of water — MID surface water from the MID main canal that runs through the ranch.

Among the many questions the investigation raised, several are outstanding:

  • How much MID surface water was actually applied out-of-District?
  • Were there conflicts of interest among directors of the study?
  • Where are the transcripts for the interviews of parties of interest?
  • Why wasn’t the Rairden property included as Board President Frobose intended?
  • Why weren’t investigators given hard copies of the irrigation plan?
  • Why didn’t the investigation pursue violations such as exceeding the MID allotment for 2022?
  • Why do billing records show Byrd’s “Master Water Account” was billed for less water than he pumped?
AB La Grange Ranch sign 10 August 2025
Iron frame by Todd Sill

Since MID farmers and ratepayers funded the investigation, they have a right to answers to these questions and more. Shortfalls in billing for MID surface water amount to subsidies paid for by MID ratepayers and in-district farmers.

If, for example, the 4Creeks investigation was directed and supervised by people who might have benefitted or suffered from transparency, that relationship needs to exposed. No in-house investigation should ever be conducted by current or former employees with their own interests at issue.

The 4Creeks investigation established irrigation requirements of almond orchards on Stanislaus County’s southeast corner with granular specificity. 4Creeks also revealed how much MID surface water was reportedly pumped onto the almond orchards on the AB La Grange Ranch. A simple comparison of pumping and power records with established orchard requirements and billing history should have been a fundamental feature of the investigation. No such comparison was offered.

Along with the failure to provide transcripts of interviews with persons of interest, MID and 4Creeks omitted the 72 acre orchard on the Rairden parcel from any review at all. Investigators said they inspected Byrd’s irrigation blueprint via “video.”  These omissions amount to a forest of red flags.

All in all, the 4Creeks investigation precipitated a dark cloud, not just over the AB La Grange Ranch, but over MID itself. That cloud won’t go away until it’s exposed to the bright light of day.

Let the sun shine in.

 

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here