Even the California Republican Party condemned Alexandra Duarte’s “target practice” campaign ad against Marie Alvarado-Gil last May. The ad showed Duarte decked out in target practice gear — ear muffs and shooting glasses — while firing a handgun at a portrait of Alvarado-Gil. Duarte was challenging Alvarado-Gil for a State Senate Seat during the May/June Primary Election.
Like many who resort to inflammatory and violent imagery, Duarte’s despicable tactics provided a smokescreen for a campaign remarkably barren of anything but rage bait and MAGA virtue signaling. Her primary campaign platform consisted mainly of a derivative slogan, “MCGA” — “Make California Great Again — and heavy doses of transphobia.
She never offered any reasons why these positions would have even marginal relevance in Sacramento, where MAGA tariffs, war in Iran, and rising costs for fuel, food and health care are just as unpopular as everywhere else in the nation.
After defeating Alvarado-Gil in the primary, Duarte has again resorted to imagery. This time her ads feature a mug shot of her opponent, Democrat Jaron Brandon, who is crushing her on the issues. The picture was taken over a decade ago, after Brandon was arrested “on suspicion of public intoxication.” The charges were dropped shortly after the arrest.
Though the mug shot could hardly be less relevant to a campaign featuring hugely important issues ranging from the costs of fire insurance to severe housing and health care shortages, it must have seemed irresistibly appealing to Janice Keating.
Keating is running for a second term on the Modesto Irrigation District (MID) Board of Directors. Her latest mailer refers to a forty-year old burglary by Michael Moradian when he was still in high school. Moradian is running against her.
The mailer features a prominent grab line saying “Someone is Keeping a Secret” and text claiming Moradian “is not telling you about his criminal past.” There’s an accompanying photo of a very young Mike Moradian in grainy black and white.
Contrary to Janice Keating’s bogus claims, Mike Moradian has been open about the theft since declaring for office. As recently as last month, Ken Carlson reported that Moradian “admitted” the theft “on a Modesto Bee candidate questionnaire.” Moradian also acknowledged the crime during a recent appearance before members of IBEW Local 1245, the union representing the majority of workers at MID. Moradian received a full pardon in 2014.

Lies are nothing new for Janice Keating. A judge ordered her to pay almost $45,000 in attorney’s fees after she falsely claimed gender harassment by MID and Board President Robert Frobose. More recently, allegations that a collision with Frobose and MID Director Larry Byrd had knocked her into the MID podium proved fraudulent when video of the incident showed she and Byrd exiting the MID boardroom in animated conversation.
Despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, another MID candidate, Dominic Giorgi, has taken up Keating’s claims of harassment both in mailers and on his website. MID union members recently revoked an endorsement of Giorgi because of false statements and exaggerations in his campaign material, among other issues. A part-time rodeo clown, Giorgi is running against MID Board President Robert Frobose.
The tawdry mendacity issuing from Duarte, Keating and Giorgi has some commonalities. All three candidates are supported by or closely associated with Stanislaus County’s east-side groundwater-guzzlers.
Alexandra’s husband, John Duarte, farms and sells groundwater-dependent crops and has been a prominent supporter of Dominic Giorgi. Ty Angle is partners with Larry and Tim Byrd on the AB La Grange Ranch, which is the subject of an investigation for water theft by the Stanislaus County District Attorney.
All three partners have donated to Janice Keating and Dominic Giorgi. Altogether, Angle associates and the Byrds have donated over $30,000 to Giorgi’s campaign. They all live and farm well outside both candidates’ districts.
Scurrilous lies and baseless innuendo pollute public discourse and lower the tone of local political life for all of us. If we’re going to indulge in political warfare, we should at least observe time-honored practices of clever invective, creative satire, sarcasm, hyperbole and self-righteous rants.
Their transparent falsehoods and desperate smear campaigns make Giorgi, Keating and Duarte look like a trio of shills riding a jackass-powered bandwagon while Ty Angle holds the reins and Larry Byrd rides shotgun, frantically tossing out free samples of east side bottled groundwater to anyone promising to vote clown all the way down.
Stanislaus region citizens deserve better.
Alexandra Duarte is also the Director/President of the Stanislaus East Mutual Water Company, a company which advocates for groundwater rights for east side growers. She has direct ties to this issue, regardless of her husband’s connection.
More info here: https://duartefacts.org/posts/water-for-farms
I’ve had quite enough of the Duarte family. Stanislaus County supervisors have looked the other way for years.
They believe — like Trump does — that laws don’t apply to them. That’s not the sort we need in government—they represent themselves only.
Instead of elevating them, they need to be held accountable.
If you haven’t already voted, turn in your ballot IN PERSON.
Not only looked the other way but Terry Withrow has actively helped the Duartes, Byrds, and that eastside group continue to damage the aquifer and environment. Withrow and Duarte have supported Byrd’s water theft at the expense of the ratepayers and continue using taxpayer money to help that eastside (aka eastside kindergarten mafia) group with their environmental damaging schemes and plots.
Eric, thank you for your continuing support for bringing the truth to issues going on in Stanislaus County. I won’t mention any names but the Board of Sups could have a scoundrel on it. Look at who is on the boards of the StanCOG issue, StanRTA issues, the Eastside water issue. “Just sayin”